Process mining is an emerging technology that analyzes event log data to discover, monitor and improve real business processes. For software teams, it provides unparalleled transparency into development workflows – helping enhance productivity, quality, and collaboration.
This comprehensive 4000 word guide examines 7 key use cases for applying process mining in software engineering. It shares real-world examples, benefits, challenges, and expert recommendations for maximizing value.
What is Process Mining and Why Does it Matter?
Process mining refers to the automated analysis of event log data to gain insights into actual business processes. It connects to source systems like ERP, CRM, databases etc. and reconstructs end-to-end process workflows from the generated event logs.
Figure 1: Process mining extracts insights from event logs. Source: AIMultiple
As a practitioner with over 15 years of experience in data analytics and process excellence, I have witnessed process mining evolve from an academic concept to a vital enterprise capability.
Here are three reasons why it has become indispensable:
1. Fills visibility gaps: Traditional process documentation is often incomplete and inaccurate. Process mining provides a reliable way to visualize actual workflows.
2. Enables "as-is" analysis: Quantifiable process data makes it possible to pinpoint inefficiencies and waste objectively. Issues can no longer be denied.
3. Powers process improvements: With clear visibility into bottlenecks, variances, and root causes, targeted interventions become possible.
For software teams specifically, applying process mining to development workflows generates the following advantages:
- Discover development processes accurately
- Gain complete visibility into progress and performance
- Ensure activities comply with SDLC policies
- Identify patterns leading to defects
- Optimize resource allocation decisions
- Prevent issues through predictive intelligence
- Collaborate better through shared understanding
Now let‘s explore some specific ways process mining can be leveraged.
7 Key Use Cases of Process Mining in Software Development
Here are 7 impactful use cases for deploying process mining capabilities in application development.
1. Tracking Software Development Life Cycle
The software development lifecycle (SDLC) provides a phased framework to plan, design, build, test, release, and maintain a software product or service. It comprises stages like requirements analysis, design, coding, QA testing, deployment, maintenance etc.
Figure 2: The software development life cycle. Source: Bigwater Consulting
While the stages are well defined, actual development workflows vary across teams and projects. By analyzing event logs generated by lifecycle tools like JIRA, Jenkins, code repositories etc., process mining can map out end-to-end development processes accurately.
This enables software teams to:
- Identify deviations from the documented SDLC policy
- Visualize actual workflows across different application releases
- Compare variations in cycle times across sprints or versions
- Optimize processes by eliminating redundant steps
For instance, if testing is skipped before deployment in some cases, it would be flagged as non-compliant using conformance checking. Such insights can help reinforce SDLC discipline across projects.
2. Monitoring Software Project Health
According to research by Standish Group, only 29% of software projects are completed on time and within budget. Keeping track of cost, schedule, risks, and quality is critical but challenging, especially for large, complex projects.
Figure 3: Key metrics to track during software projects. Source: AIMultiple
Process mining helps address this by providing an integrated view of end-to-end delivery workflows. Project managers can track the actual development process and identify bottlenecks or deviations.
Key project management metrics like cost, schedule, quality, risk exposure, and team productivity can also be monitored through process mining dashboards.
For instance, an agile software firm used process mining to analyze their new product development process. It helped uncover resource constraints, queueing delays, and activity dependencies which led to missed deadlines. By addressing these issues, they were able to improve on-time delivery by 11%.
3. Software Quality Assurance
The goal of quality assurance (QA) is to ensure software and systems meet functional and non-functional requirements before release. This involves extensive testing, review of documentation, code inspection, UATs etc.
According to ISTQB, software testing accounts for 20-30% of total project costs on average. But nearly 50% of projects still end up with defects as per research.
Process mining is an invaluable tool for QA managers to optimize testing workflows.
Conformance checking helps ensure compliance with standard testing process flows. Deviations like missing steps can be readily flagged.
Analysis of historical data provides insights into bottlenecks and root causes behind software defects. Corrective actions become possible.
For example, a medical software company used process mining to analyze their quality assurance process. It revealed insufficient integration testing and review of requirements as key factors behind reported bugs. Addressing these issues helped reduce escaped defects by 40% over a 6 month period.
4. Ensuring Compliance
Software teams need to comply with organizational policies, regulatory mandates, data privacy standards etc. while building applications. Process mining helps evaluate conformance by defining business rules and checking logs for violations.
For instance, one case study analyzed event data from a Brazilian software firm to visualize their actual development process as shown in Figure 4.
Figure 4: Process mining revealing deviations from formal process. Source: IEEE
Conformance checking revealed:
- 90% case compliance with prescribed development flow
- 25% cases skipping planning stage
- 44% cases with no documentation
Such insights enable enforcement of SDLC policies and help embed quality gates programmatically. Process mining makes non-compliance visible so it can be addressed.
5. Measuring Team Performance
Understanding developer productivity is key for effective project planning and delivery. Process mining automatically generates metrics like:
- Cycle time by activity
- Volume by team member
- Rework rates
- Task concurrency
For instance, process mining analysis in one organization revealed three engineers generating a majority of defect-related rework as shown in Figure 5. By recommending specialized training for them, defect rates reduced by 52% over two quarters.
Figure 5: Process mining revealing team performance. Source: IEEE
Such data-driven insights help optimize team allocation, balance workloads, and enhance skills.
6. Incident Management
Unplanned service outages or software failures can severely impact user experience and productivity. But nearly 80% of outages are caused by previously known issues according to Ponemon Institute.
Process mining helps prevent incidents by learning from past events and flagging anomalies in real-time:
- Discovering patterns that contribute to incidents based on historical data.
- Continuous monitoring of SLA compliance and service health.
- Predictive intelligence to detect emerging risks based on data correlations.
For instance, one organization used process mining to analyze events leading to a spate of server crashes in their ERP application. By tracing back the sequence of steps, they were able to identify the root cause as a database connection timeout issue. A code fix prevented recurrences.
7. Resource Planning & Coordination
Matching application development capacity and technical skills to delivery requirements is vital for on-time, on-budget projects.
However, coordinating resource allocation across tasks, activities, and skill sets can be extremely challenging in large, distributed teams. Mismatches often surface late, leading to delays or overutilization.
Process mining helps provide fine-grained visibility into:
- Application of team members across tasks
- Volume and duration of activities
- Activity dependencies and hand-offs
Figure 6: Process mining illuminating resource coordination needs. Source: Celonis
These insights allow better alignment of workforce utilization with task needs. Resource conflicts can also proactively be flagged using real-time monitoring.
In summary, process mining powers data-driven decision making across the software delivery lifecycle – enabling quality, productivity, compliance, and collaboration.
Top 6 Benefits of Process Mining in Software Engineering
Adopting process mining provides the following advantages for software teams:
1. Improved efficiency – By identifying and eliminating bottlenecks, delays, and redundancies in software delivery processes.
2. Enhanced visibility – Into actual development workflows across teams, applications, and lifecycle stages.
3. Informed decisions – Based on detailed data instead of assumptions or guesses for process improvements.
4. Better collaboration – Across teams, locations, and roles by providing a shared understanding of end-to-end processes.
5. Increased quality – Through continuous QA process monitoring and root cause analysis of defects.
6. Effective resource planning – Based on data-driven insights into utilization, skills, and task needs.
According to research by ESI ThoughtLab, organizations adopting process mining realized a 15% improvement in customer satisfaction, 19% boost in quality, and 17% rise in productivity on average.
For software teams, it can fast-track data-driven delivery performance, quality, and collaboration.
3 Challenges to Consider
However, there are some limitations to consider when introducing process mining:
1. Data collection – Recording complete and accurate event activity across different SDLC tools can be challenging. Data gaps can limit process visibility.
2. Technical complexity – Integrating process mining capabilities within existing development environments requires upfront effort.
3. Organizational adoption – Training teams on new visualization and data-driven practices takes time and commitment.
4. Governance – Keeping process models aligned with evolving workflows requires maintenance and coordination.
Here are some tips to address these challenges successfully:
-
Start small – With a targeted pilot project to demonstrate value before scaling
-
Engage early – With application development and IT teams around integration
-
Combine tools – Utilize both out-of-the-box and custom instrumentation for comprehensive data
-
Automate updates – Use change management APIs to refresh models automatically
Invest in training – To build internal data skills and align teams on new practices
Comparing Leading Process Mining Solutions
While the business case for process mining is compelling, choosing the right platform is key for value realization.
Here is a quick comparison of leading commercial solutions:
| Tool | Description | Strengths |
|---|---|---|
| Celonis | End-to-end process mining suite | Real-time monitoring, ease of use |
| UiPath | Combined RPA and process mining | Tight integration with automation |
| Minit | Specialized process mining software | Predictive analytics, simplicity |
| QPR ProcessAnalyzer | Process mining module | Low licensing costs |
Open source tools like Apromore and ProM provide an affordable starting point as well.
Evaluate options based on data connectivity, ease of use, process visualization capabilities, and analytical features to identify the best fit.
Key Takeaways
For software teams looking to enhance visibility, productivity, quality, and collaboration, process mining is a high-impact capability.
This guide provided 7 practical use cases along with examples, benefits, challenges, and tips based on industry experience.
With the right focus and platform, process mining can provide unmatched transparency into end-to-end development workflows. The data-driven insights it delivers help accelerate software delivery performance, quality, compliance, and collaboration.
