In my decade as a web scraping expert advising Fortune 500 companies, the most common question I get asked is:
"Should we build in-house scraping capabilities or use an external cloud provider?"
It‘s an important dilemma, with arguments on both sides. In this comprehensive guide, I‘ll share my insider perspective to help you make the right decision for your organization.
The Growing Importance of Web Scraping
Let‘s first look at why web scraping has become so critical for businesses today:
-
Exponential data growth online: Over 1.7MB of data is created on the internet every second – research from DOMO. That‘s a massive treasure trove of web data waiting to be tapped.
-
Competitive edge: In a 2019 survey by MIT Sloan Management Review, 85% of executives said scraping web data gives them a competitive advantage. It reveals consumer trends, monitors competitors, improves products and more.
-
Automated decisions: Web data is enabling automated decision-making across operations – from dynamic pricing to personalized recommendations to predictive analytics.
As per Allied Market Research, the global web scraping market size already stands at $2.6 billion and is growing at 13.7% CAGR. It‘s clear that web scraping is rapidly becoming a must-have capability rather than just a "nice-to-have".
Option 1 – In-House Web Scraping
Let‘s explore the pros and cons of building in-house web scraping capabilities.
How it Works
Developing web scrapers in-house involves:
- Recruiting data engineers to code complex scraping scripts and bots.
- Building a distributed computing infrastructure on-premise to deploy scrapers at scale.
- Storing and processing huge volumes of scraped data.
Maintaining production-grade scrapers requires specialization in domains like data engineering, DevOps, cybersecurity etc.
It‘s a heavy lift requiring months of work even for experienced teams.
Cost Considerations
While individual scrapers can be built fast, developing an enterprise-grade scraping infrastructure has high costs:
- Specialized talent comes at a premium. Average salary for an experienced data engineer is $130K (Glassdoor). You need a team of at least 4-5 engineers.
- With optimizing algorithms, handling JS rendering, proxies etc. – building complex scrapers can take 200-300 engineering hours.
- On-premise infrastructure for web crawling at scale could cost upwards of $100K.
- Ongoing maintenance and upgrades requires dedicated engineering bandwidth.
For large organizations scraping millions of pages, in-house development costs can easily cross $500K+ in upfront investment.
The Benefits
However, investing in in-house web scraping capabilities has significant benefits:
-
Full control: You own the technology stack and can customize it as needed for your evolving business requirements.
-
Data privacy: Sensitive web data remains completely within your infrastructure without third-party exposure.
-
Lower long-term costs: At large scale scraping volumes, in-house becomes much cheaper than outsourcing.
For example, a retail company scraping 100 million product pages a month was able to recover their $200K upfront investment in less than 6 months through lower operational costs.
The Challenges
Despite the benefits, developing in-house web scraping capabilities has inherent challenges:
-
Scarce expertise: There is a worldwide shortage of talent skilled in web scraping technology. Hard to recruit and retain.
-
Long timelines: For enterprise use cases, even experienced teams need 4-6 months minimum to develop production-grade scrapers. Not ideal for agile environments.
-
Scaling limitations: In-house infrastructure cannot easily handle spikes in scraping demand. You risk missing out on valuable data.
-
Frequent rework: With websites constantly changing, scrapers need frequent maintenance. This drives up long-term costs.
-
Compliance risks: Without proper oversight, scrapers could violate sites‘ policies leading to legal issues.
So in summary, in-house web scraping requires heavy investment but provides better control and lower costs at massive scale. The downsides are long timelines and ongoing complexity.
Option 2 – Cloud Web Scraping Services
Now let‘s explore SaaS-based solutions for web data extraction.
How it Works
Instead of building in-house, you leverage specialist software vendors who provide web scraping as a cloud service. Their platform handles the complexity:
- Advanced crawling engines to scrape even complex websites.
- Distributed cloud servers for blazing fast scraping at massive scale.
- Data processing and storage so you get structured data ready for analysis.
You simply configure the target sites and data needs through their portal. Some even offer browser extensions for ad-hoc scraping needs.
Cost Considerations
Cloud scraping services are offered on a pay-as-you-go pricing model based on:
- Number of page visits or API calls
- Data processing and structuring requirements
- Data volumes extracted
For small scale needs of less than 50K pages/month, pricing starts around $500 per month.
At 500K+ pages/month, costs are approx. $5000+ per month.
Costs scale up with the amount of scraping you require. But you only pay for what you use.
The Benefits
The biggest value propositions of using a cloud scraping service are:
-
Rapid deployment: You can start extracting web data in days instead of months. Ideal when you need insights quickly.
-
No infrastructure costs: Removes the need for in-house engineering and DevOps teams for web scraping.
-
Scales on demand: Cloud platforms easily handle seasonal spikes in data needs. No risk of missing data due to bottlenecks.
-
Superior success rates: Vendors invest heavily in optimizing their crawling engines. Certain sites like Yelp, Amazon etc. can only be scraped at scale by specialists.
-
Enhanced compliance: Reputable vendors implement robust data compliance measures like consent filters, captchas etc. Reduces your risk.
For example, a marketing analytics startup was able to scale up to scraping over 1 million pages a day within 2 weeks by leveraging a cloud platform. This enabled real-time industry monitoring and sped up their sales cycle.
The Challenges
However, there are trade-offs you make by relying on an external vendor:
-
Vendor dependence: You lose control to external factors like changes to their platform, pricing etc. which could disrupt operations.
-
Data privacy risks: Your sensitive data is processed outside of your premises. Requires robust security reviews of potential vendors.
-
Long term costs: While cloud scraping provides better economics at low scale, the pay-per-use cost model gets prohibitively expensive at enterprise scale.
So in summary, cloud platforms enable quick access to web data at moderate scale without infrastructure investments. But come with loss of control and high costs at large scale.
Key Factors in Making the Right Choice
In my experience, there‘s no one-size-fits-all answer to the build vs buy dilemma for web scraping. The right strategic choice depends on your specific situation:
1. Current and Projected Scale
-
For scraping less than 100K pages/month – cloud scraping offers better TCO without large investments.
-
For 500K+ pages/month – in-house development starts yielding better returns due to lower operational costs.
2. Strategic Importance
-
If web scraping is supplementary to your business, the flexibility of cloud makes sense.
-
For core competencies highly reliant on web data, in-house provides better control and risk management.
3. Agility Requirements
-
If you need to rapidly start extracting web insights, cloud scraping allows near instant access.
-
If your data needs are predictable, you can invest time upfront in developing in-house capabilities.
4. Data Sensitivity
-
The higher the compliance needs, the greater the benefit of keeping web scraping in-house.
-
For non-personal web data, risks from using external providers are mitigated.
Evolving from Cloud to In-House Scraping
For most organizations starting out, I typically recommend beginning with an external cloud scraping provider. This allows fast access to web data with minimal investment.
Once your needs grow in scale or strategic importance, you can start migrating certain high-value scraping workflows in-house. This gives the ideal combination of speed, flexibility and control.
Here are my recommended steps for evolving cloud to in-house web scraping capabilities:
1. Start with critical sites: Shift scraping of your most important sites like core industry forums, key competitor sites etc. in-house. These likely have high data value.
2. Build in-house scaling ability: Develop technical architecture for easy scaling like containerized scraping bots, cloud data lakes etc. This prepares you for expanding.
3. Sunset less critical scraping: As in-house capability matures, start discontinuing outsourced scraping for non-core sites. Move them in-house or cease altogether.
4. Control spikes via cloud: During temporary spikes where in-house capacity is saturated, leverage external provider for overflow needs. This provides a release valve without over-building in-house.
5. Maintain as backup: Even after migrating most scraping in-house, keep trusted cloud provider contract for contingencies. Serves as an insurance policy.
Key Takeaways
Here are my top recommendations for business leaders considering web scraping:
-
Start by outsourcing to a cloud provider to gain speed to insight.
-
Focus in-house resources on consuming and operationalizing web data.
-
For core web data needs, develop custom scrapers in-house for control and scale.
-
Take an hybrid approach to balance flexibility, control and economics.
-
Work with reputable vendors who implement ethical scraping practices.
I hope this guide provides valuable insights as you navigate the complex world of web scraping. Feel free to reach out for any specific advisory needed for your organization.