Securing Your Domain‘s Certificates with DNS CAA Records

Do you control who can issue TLS/SSL certificates for your organization‘s domains? If not, your websites are vulnerable to serious cyber threats. By using an often neglected DNS record type – Certification Authority Authorization (CAA) – you can lock down certificate issuance to approved CAs only.

In this comprehensive guide, I‘ll equip you with in-depth knowledge to immediately implement CAA records yourself. First the basics…

The Vital Role of CAA Records

Before diving into CAA syntax, let me provide some context…

The TLS certificate ecosystem has numerous risks, as evidenced by large-scale misissuance incidents from private CAs in recent years. These could have been prevented with proper CAA records.

Shockingly though, a 2021 survey found less than 13% of the Alexa Top Million domains had CAA records implemented.

By using CAA records, you explicitly authorize only trusted Certificate Authorities to issue certificates for your domains. This prevents unauthorized third parties from acquiring certificates without consent to intercept traffic or conduct cyberattacks.

I‘ll be referencing some advanced concepts about certificates, so don‘t hesitate to ask me any clarifying questions! My goal is to help expand your knowledge as we work through this guide together. Sound good? Excellent, let‘s continue…

Anatomy of CAA Records

CAA records have a special syntax that allows specifying one or more authorized CA domain names. Here is the technical format:

example.com. CAA 0 issue "ca1.com"
example.com. CAA 128 iodef "[email protected]"

While that may look confusing, I‘ll break it down piece-by-piece:

  • example.com – The domain name the record applies to
  • CAA – Indicates this is a CAA record
  • 0 – Setting special flags (usually 0)
  • issue – Authorizes certificate issue only for this exact domain
  • "ca1.com" – Domain name of approved Certificate Authority
  • iodef – Provides an email for CA security notifications

Now that you know how to interpret their syntax, let‘s put that knowledge into action…

Here are two sample CAA record configurations for securing certificates on your domains:

company.com CAA 0 issue "digicert.com" 

*.company.com CAA 0 issuewild "digicert.com"
*.company.com CAA 128 iodef "[email protected]" 

As you can see, the issuewild keyword authorizes wildcard certificates to be issued by Digicert. This is then limited to just Digicert using issue for the root.

Adoption Trends Across Industries

CAA records have seen steady growth since 2018, however adoption varies greatly based on industry:

Industry % CAA Adoption
Finance 38%
Information Technology 29%
Education 19%
Retail 3%

And regionally, North America leads the way with 34% adoption versus 24% in Europe.

[insert data visualization chart]

Now that you understand their importance, let‘s shift our focus towards deployment…

Validating CAA Records

I‘ll demonstrate how to easily validate your CAA records are properly configured…

Use the dig command to query a domain‘s DNS records and filter for just CAA types:

dig company.com CAA +short

You can also use the handy DNS CAA Tester tool I mentioned earlier.

Now let‘s get your records set up securely.

Configuring Air-Tight CAA Records

Follow my simple 4 step methodology to bulletproof your CAA records:

Step 1) Determine 2-3 trusted CAs to authorize

Step 2) Construct approproate CAA records for each CA

Step 3) Add CAA records through your DNS provider

Step 4) Validate records are present using dig & online tools

To help you apply that in practice, here is a sample scenario:

Your company XYZ Corp uses both public and private PKI certificates across multiple domains and subdomains. You want to authorize Digicert and Sectigo to give flexibility. Require email alerts for misissuance violations.

Given those requirements, your CAA records would be:

xyzcorp.com CAA 0 issue "digicert.com"
xyzcorp.com CAA 0 issue “sectigo.com”

*.xyzcorp.com CAA 0 issuewild “digicert.com”  
*.xyzcorp.com CAA 0 issuewild “sectigo.com”
*.xyzcorp.com CAA 128 iodef “[email protected]

This grants either Digicert or Sectigo ability to issue public wildcard certificates. Any policy violations would also send alerts to your security team for rapid response.

Troubleshooting Common CAA Issues

Let‘s shift gears to tackle common CAA problems that arise:

  • Unauthorized certificates – Monitor closely for any certs issues from outside allowed CAs and immediately file revocation. Update your records to prevent further misissuance.

  • Zone errors – DNS resolver failures can provide outdated cached records. Flush caches and validate with multiple tools.

  • Wildcards too broad – Audit records and consider restricting wildcards only to infrastructure needing that flexibility.

For all troubleshooting:

  1. Reproduce the error
  2. Compare configurations across tools
  3. Methodically confirm expected state

This eliminates user error and zone issues as potential culprits.

Best Practices for Managing CAA

Let‘s conclude with vital tips for operating CAA records smoothly:

Proactively update records on CA changes – Give plenty of lead time for propagation to minimize issuance failures.

Automate audits and alerts for record validity – Use scripted monitoring to catch issues early.

Review authorized CA list yearly – Adjust as your certificate usage evolves.

Specify contacts for issuer violations via iodef – Enables swift response on rogue certificates.

I hope this journey demystifying CAA records has shown their immense value for securing critical certificates safe from misuse.

It‘s past time all domain owners implemented this powerful capability. Take charge by putting these precise instructions into play. My advice is to start with your highest risk domains then expand CAA coverage.

Now you have no excuses preventing you from locking down your TLS certificates! Just let me know if any guidance within this guide needs clarification. I‘m here to provide expert support ensuring your success using CAA records.

Go forth, implement robust controls with confidence, and conquer certificate threats!

Tags: