Choosing Between OLAP and OLTP Systems: An In-Depth Guide

Online analytical processing (OLAP) and online transaction processing (OLTP) are critical systems that help organizations unlock value from their data. This comprehensive guide will explain key aspects of OLAP and OLTP to help you determine the right system based on your requirements.

Content Navigation show

Introduction: OLAP vs OLTP

According to Gartner, over 75% of large enterprises actively use OLAP systems while over 90% rely on OLTP systems to run their daily operations [1]. But what exactly are OLAP and OLTP, and what are some key differences?

OLAP or Online Analytical Processing refers to solutions and architectures optimized for complex analytical queries on historical, multidimensional data for activities like reporting, forecasting and predictive modeling.

OLTP or Online Transactional Processing refers to systems optimized for speed and efficiency in processing high volumes of operational transactions such as orders, payments, inventory updates, etc. involving reads, inserts, updates and deletes.

Now let‘s deep dive into their key characteristics, architecture, uses cases, limitations and how they compare across various parameters.

System Architecture

OLAP Architecture

OLAP architecture follows a multi-tier data warehousing approach:

Data from sources like ERP, CRM, databases is extracted and fed into the warehouse through ETL jobs. This process also cleanses, transforms and enriches the data as needed.
The data warehouse structures data into multidimensional OLAP cubes that allow analysts to slice and dice data across different attributes and hierarchies. For instance,sales could be analyzed by region, product, channel as well as time periods like year, quarter, month, day etc.
On the front-end, reporting, dashboards and advanced analytics tools access these OLAP cubes to uncover insights through trend analysis, forecasts, simulations and complex queries.

OLTP Architecture

A typical OLTP system has a 3-tier logical architecture:

The client or presentation tier provides the user interface for initiating and responding to database transactions. For example, data entry forms in a mobile app.
The application or business logic tier implements workflows related to transaction management like validation, processing rules, communication with other systems etc.
The database tier physically persists the transactional data and supports querying, manipulation through SQL etc. Popular relational databases like Oracle, MySQL and SQL Server support OLTP use cases.

In terms of scalability, OLTP systems are designed to scale well horizontally while analytical systems require more vertical scaling up especially for the database tier.

Key Characteristics

OLAP Characteristics

Optimized for read-heavy analytical workloads marked by long, complex queries.
Leverages both historical and current data from a variety of sources.
Allows drilling down data across multiple dimensions like region, product etc.
Columnar database storage perfect for aggregate queries over large data volumes.
Outputs include management reports, visualizations and predictions from statistical models.

For instance, an OLAP system can analyze multi-year sales trends by region, traffic source and demographic segments in seconds.

OLTP Characteristics

Optimized for write-heavy transactional workloads dominated by a high volume of simple, short updates, inserts and deletes.
Provides access to current operational data representing the system‘s current state.
Row database storage allows fast single row lookups and updates common in transactions.
Emphasis is on throughput, consistency, integrity and low latency.
Outputs relate to transaction processing like order confirmations, account updates etc.

For example, at peak load, PayPal processes some 200+ transactions per second leveraging OLTP architecture [2].

Use Cases

OLAP Use Cases

Generation of periodic management reports and dashboards across historical data.
Data mining to discover hidden patterns and relationships.
Building financial models for forecasting, budgeting.
Statistical analysis and modeling techniques for predictive analytics.
Ad hoc querying and analysis by business analysts.
Analysis across various attributes, hierarchies and consolidations.

For instance, Netflix analyses historical viewing behavior and combines it with customer info to power their content recommendations engine.

OLTP Use Cases

Purchases, payments, orders processing, account updates.
Retail point-of-sale (POS) checkout transactions.
User-facing applications like self-service portals, reservation systems.
Messaging systems sending and recording millions of event messages per second.
Call detail recording in telecom firms processing over 50,000 concurrent calls.
IoT sensor data collection and dissemination infrastructure.

Examples like Uber, Amazon leverage OLTP to support their core transactional use cases at scale even during traffic surges like Black Friday.

Benefits

Benefits of OLAP

Analyze historical data to uncover trends, root causes and opportunities.
Simulate business scenarios using forecasting models.
Deliver insights to stakeholders via interactive reports and dashboards.
Guide strategy decisions around markets, pricing, inventory planning etc.
Democratize data access for non-technical users through self-service BI tools.

For example, OLAP powers Amazon‘s inventory planning leveraging predictive demand forecasting models.

Benefits of OLTP

Achieve high transaction throughput essential for customer-facing systems.
Ensure low latency transaction response times.
Support large user concurrency and traffic spikes during peak periods.
Maintain data integrity as transactions can span multiple systems.
Index data properly to optimize database performance.

A major European bank leverages OLTP systems to reliably process over 150 million transactions per week across its enterprise [3].

Limitations

OLAP Limitations

Not optimized to handle real-time transactional updates at scale.
Near real-time refreshes to reports and analytical models are challenging.
Generally not meant for operational business applications.
Poorly designed models can negatively impact performance of OLTP source systems.

OLTP Limitations

Not optimized for the large aggregations and joins typical in analytical queries.
Limited historical data retention due to disk space constraints.
Lack access controls, custom views and sharing capabilities beyond basics.
Often miss analytical capabilities to unlock insights.

For instance, an attempt to run a complex SELECT counting over 10+ database tables with millions of rows can bring typical OLTP systems to a crawl.

Comparison Between OLAP and OLTP

Parameter	OLAP	OLTP
Data Scope	Historical, aggregated data	Current operational data
Schema Design	Star/Snowflake, denormalized	Normalized relational
Query Complexity	Complex analytical queries	Simple transactional queries
Performance Need	Throughput and fast aggregations	Low latency
Concurrency	100s to 1000s of users	10,000s to 100,000s users
Data Updates	Batch updates	Real-time, concurrent updates
End Users	Analysts, management	Customer apps, internal apps
Use Cases	Reporting, analytics	Transaction processing
Tools	BI, visualization, statistical	CRUD apps, message queues

This table highlights some key differences even though both classes of systems process data to enable critical business processes eventually.

Recommendations on When to Choose

When to Choose OLAP

I would recommend OLAP systems when your priority is to analyze large volumes of historical data to uncover trends, root causes or answering questions to guide strategic decisions across areas like:

Sales performance optimization
Production and inventory planning
Pricing strategy formulation
Campaign effectiveness measurement
Human resource capacity planning based on trends

When to Choose OLTP

My recommendation would be to leverage OLTP architectures for use cases involving:

Mission-critical transactions supporting your core business operations.
Applicability across customer-facing applications.
Need for minimal processing latency during updates.
Requirements related to scale, concurrency and throughput.
Strong data accuracy and integrity considerations.

For instance, OLTP systems are great for order processing workflows, inventory status updates, payment transactions etc.

Using OLAP and OLTP Together

While OLAP and OLTP serve distinct purposes individually, modern data architectures often combine both modalities together to enable analytics-driven business processes leveraging insights, predictions and patterns generated from OLAP analysis.

Some popular ways to use both paradigms together include:

Using ETL pipelines to feed key transactional data from OLTP databases into an enterprise data warehouse optimized for analytical processing. AWS offers services like Glue to help build such data lakes.
Enabling dynamic lookups between operational systems and analytics engines – for instance, retrieving a customer‘s lifetime value stored in a OLAP dataset before approving a real-time transaction.
Building hybrid operational analytical systems that can handle analytical and transactional workloads on the same platform. Examples include Oracle Exadata, Teradata‘s offerings etc.

If aligned closely to business goals, synergies between OLAP and OLTP systems can accelerate data-driven decision automation to new levels.

Conclusion

In closing, while their architecture, capabilities and use cases differ significantly, OLAP and OLTP provide complementary value in terms of analytics versus operations. As discussed through various examples, leading enterprises leverage both these paradigms closely to build data moats and drive growth. I hope the detailed comparisons and recommendations in this guide help you determine the right approach based on your system needs and objectives. Please feel free to reach out in case any part needs further clarification.

References

[1] Gartner
[2] PayPal Engineering Blog
[3] American Banker 2021 Report