If you‘re a vegan who loves to shop at Trader Joe‘s, you may have eyed the ever-popular Cookie Butter and wondered – is this decadent dessert spread vegan-friendly? The short answer is no, but there‘s much more to unpack. As a picky shopper and consumer analyst, I‘ve done a deep dive into the world of cookie butter to give you all the facts you need to make an informed purchasing decision.
The Cookie Butter Craze
First, let‘s rewind to the origins of the cookie butter phenomenon. This spread made from crushed spice cookies (speculoos) originated in Belgium under the brand Lotus Biscoff. In 2011, Trader Joe‘s launched its own version of speculoos cookie butter and it quickly became a cult favorite.
Sales of cookie butter have skyrocketed over the past decade. According to market research firm IRI, sales of Biscoff and Trader Joe‘s cookie butter reached $35.8 million in 2018, up from just $1.1 million in 2011. The popularity has led to spin-off products like cookie butter ice cream and cheesecake.
Food industry analyst Phil Lempert attributes the cookie butter craze to factors like novelty, indulgence, and limited availability. "Cookie butter taps into the emotional appeal of cookies while providing a new way to enjoy that flavor," he says. "Consumers view it as a treat and the fact that it‘s not available everywhere adds to the specialness."
Ingredients & Nutritional Drawbacks
Now let‘s examine what‘s actually inside Trader Joe‘s Speculoos Cookie Butter:
| Ingredient | Amount per 2 Tbsp Serving |
|---|---|
| Calories | 180 |
| Total Fat | 11g |
| Saturated Fat | 3.5g |
| Sodium | 60mg |
| Total Carbohydrate | 20g |
| Total Sugars | 13g |
| Protein | 1g |
The first red flag for vegans is the presence of palm oil. While technically plant-based, many vegans avoid palm oil due to the environmental destruction caused by its production. Palm oil plantations are a major driver of deforestation in Southeast Asia, threatening the habitat of endangered species like orangutans.
According to the World Wildlife Fund, an area the equivalent size of 300 football fields of rainforest is cleared every hour to make way for palm oil production. The palm oil industry is also rife with human rights abuses including child labor and unsafe working conditions.
Another issue is the allergy warning that the cookie butter "may contain traces of tree nuts, milk and eggs." This means there‘s a risk of cross-contamination from shared equipment, which is problematic for stricter vegans. Trace amounts of animal products can still be significant for those with allergies.
From a nutritional standpoint, cookie butter is far from a health food. Besides the ethical issues with palm oil, it‘s high in calories, fat and sugar without offering much nutritional value. Registered dietitian Alissa Rumsey explains that cookie butter "falls into the same category as Nutella or frosting. It‘s fine as an occasional treat, but shouldn‘t be considered a nutritious staple."
To put it in perspective, a 2 tablespoon serving of cookie butter contains 13 grams of sugar. That‘s over half of the maximum daily amount of 25 grams recommended for women by the American Heart Association. Regularly consuming foods high in added sugars can contribute to chronic health issues like diabetes and heart disease over time.
Vegan-Friendly Alternatives
If you‘re committed to a vegan lifestyle but still crave the indulgent flavor of cookie butter, don‘t despair. You have several alternatives to try:
-
Homemade vegan cookie butter: By making your own cookie butter at home, you have full control over the ingredients. Blogger Rainbow Plant Life has a popular recipe using coconut oil instead of palm oil. You can customize it with gluten-free cookies or nut butter to suit your preferences.
-
Lotus Biscoff Cookie Butter: If you want the OG cookie butter experience, the good news is that Lotus Biscoff Cookie Butter is accidentally vegan. It‘s more widely available than Trader Joe‘s version – check your local supermarket or World Market. Just be mindful that it still contains palm oil and sugar.
-
Nut butter blends: For a healthier alternative, look for almond or cashew butter blended with dates or coconut sugar for natural sweetness. Brands like Wild Friends and Nutzo offer dessert-flavored nut butters like Snickerdoodle or Cinnamon Raisin that can scratch the cookie butter itch.
-
Homemade date spread: For a whole food option, blend pitted Medjool dates with a little water or plant milk until spreadable. Mix in cinnamon, vanilla extract, and a pinch of salt for a caramel-like flavor that pairs well with fruit or toast. Dates are high in fiber and nutrients like potassium and magnesium.
The Trader Joe‘s Difference
If you‘re wondering why Trader Joe‘s cookie butter specifically gets so much hype, a lot has to do with the store‘s unique business model. Trader Joe‘s doesn‘t manufacture any of its own products directly. Instead, it partners with suppliers to develop private label versions of trending foods and beverages.
According to retail analyst Brittain Ladd, this enables Trader Joe‘s to jump on food fads quickly and offer lower prices than competitors. "Trader Joe‘s has a finger on the pulse of what consumers want," Ladd says. "They‘re constantly sourcing new and exciting products, which creates a ‘treasure hunt‘ experience that keeps shoppers coming back."
However, the lack of transparency around Trader Joe‘s suppliers can be troubling for vegans and those with food allergies. The company is notoriously tight-lipped about its product sourcing, making it difficult to trace ingredients back to their origins. Critics argue this allows Trader Joe‘s to greenwash its image while failing to take responsibility for ethical issues in its supply chain.
For concerned consumers, the best approach is to educate yourself on the ingredients and certifications to look for. Prioritize products with short, recognizable ingredient lists and trusted third-party certifications like USDA Organic, Non-GMO Project Verified, or Fair Trade Certified.
Global Cookie Butter Variations
The cookie butter craze isn‘t limited to the US – variations on this spreadable treat can be found around the world. In Europe, where speculoos cookies originate, cookie butter is a popular souvenir. German company Lotus produces a "Biscoff Pasta" that‘s a dead ringer for the Trader Joe‘s product.
In Southeast Asia, cookie butter takes a savory turn with the addition of spices like curry and chili. Singapore-based company Irvins sells a "Salted Egg Speculoos Spread" flavored with duck egg yolks that has developed its own cult following.
The globalization of food trends like cookie butter reflects the interconnectedness of our modern food system. While this enables us to experience diverse flavors, it‘s important to consider the social and environmental impact of our food choices on communities around the world.
The Bottom Line
So is Trader Joe‘s Cookie Butter vegan? Ultimately, that depends on your personal definition of veganism and how strictly you adhere to it. From an ingredient standpoint, the cookie butter does not contain animal products. However, the presence of palm oil and cross-contamination risk will likely be dealbreakers for many vegans.
Nutritionally, cookie butter is more of an indulgence than a health food. Enjoying it mindfully in moderation is key – pair it with nourishing whole foods like fruit or whole grain toast for a balanced snack.
If you do choose to purchase cookie butter, consider seeking out alternatives to Trader Joe‘s that have transparent sourcing and commitment to sustainability. Vote with your dollars for companies that align with your ethics.
At the end of the day, being an informed and empowered consumer is about more than reading nutrition labels. It‘s about understanding the broader impact of our food choices on animals, the planet, and marginalized communities. By staying curious and thinking critically, we can spread compassion with every bite.
