If you‘re a regular Sam‘s Club shopper, you‘re probably familiar with the Member‘s Mark brand. This private label offers a wide variety of food and household products, often at lower prices than name brand equivalents. Member‘s Mark has become especially known for its fresh meat, including an extensive lineup of chicken products.
As a retail industry analyst and consumer advocate, I‘m fascinated by the growth of private label brands and the complex supply chains behind them. While Member‘s Mark chicken is a popular choice for many shoppers, most probably don‘t know much about where it actually comes from or how it‘s produced.
To uncover the story behind Member‘s Mark chicken, I‘ve done extensive research into Sam‘s Club sourcing practices, poultry industry dynamics, and consumer trends. Let‘s dive in to the details and data that can help you make more informed choices about the chicken you buy.
Following the Chicken Trail: Is Tyson Foods the Supplier Behind Member‘s Mark?
When it comes to private label products, retailers rarely disclose exactly who makes each item. Stores like Sam‘s Club work out contracted manufacturing deals with various suppliers, but these arrangements are kept confidential for competitive reasons.
However, after analyzing the available evidence, I believe it‘s highly likely that Tyson Foods is the primary supplier of Member‘s Mark chicken. Here‘s why:
-
Tyson Foods is the largest U.S. chicken producer, with a 21% market share as of 2019.[^1] The company runs a massive operation spanning the entire poultry supply chain, including breeder farms, hatcheries, feed mills, broiler farms, and processing plants.[^2]
-
Tyson has the capacity and infrastructure to supply large volumes of chicken to major retailers. In 2020, Tyson processed an average of 45 million chickens per week across its U.S. facilities.[^3] The company‘s vertically integrated model helps ensure a consistent supply of chicken with efficient cost control.
-
Tyson has long-standing business ties with Walmart, which is the parent company of Sam‘s Club. Tyson is a major supplier for Walmart‘s grocery business, and analysts estimate that Walmart purchases account for a significant portion of Tyson‘s sales.[^4]
-
Member‘s Mark chicken products specify attributes like "no antibiotics ever" that align with Tyson‘s practices. In 2019, Tyson announced that all of its Tyson-branded chicken would be raised without any antibiotics, expanding a program that had previously covered about half of its production.[^5]
While I don‘t have insider information to definitively confirm that Tyson makes Member‘s Mark chicken, this theory fits the available facts. Tyson‘s massive scale, long history with Walmart, and shift toward antibiotic-free production make the company a logical choice to supply chicken for Sam‘s Club.
It‘s also possible that Sam‘s Club sources some of its chicken from other major producers like Pilgrim‘s Pride, Perdue Farms, or Sanderson Farms. However, Tyson‘s market dominance and Walmart ties still make it the most likely primary supplier in my estimation.
Poultry Production 101: Standards & Practices Behind Member‘s Mark Chicken
Whether or not Tyson Foods is indeed the manufacturer, all Member‘s Mark chicken has to meet certain standards and labeling requirements. Here‘s a rundown of the key attributes that Sam‘s Club specifies:
-
No antibiotics: Member‘s Mark chickens are raised without any antibiotics, including for growth promotion or disease prevention. This is a major selling point at a time when consumers are increasingly concerned about overuse of antibiotics in animal agriculture.
-
No added hormones or steroids: Like all chicken sold in the U.S., Member‘s Mark products cannot contain any added hormones or steroids. While this is a common label claim, it‘s worth noting that federal law already prohibits hormone/steroid use in chicken.[^6]
-
Vegetarian diet: Member‘s Mark chickens are fed a 100% vegetarian diet containing no animal byproducts. However, this is a standard practice in the industry since broiler chickens are typically fed corn and soybean meal.[^7]
-
USDA inspection: All Member‘s Mark chicken is inspected by USDA‘s Food Safety and Inspection Service to ensure it meets quality and safety standards. USDA grading also assesses factors like meat yield, fat content, and appearance.[^8]
While these standards provide some assurances, Member‘s Mark chicken almost certainly comes from large-scale factory farming rather than smaller, more sustainable operations. Broiler chickens in these systems are typically raised in crowded indoor grow-out houses, with about 0.8 square feet of space per bird.[^9]
Animal welfare is an area where retailers are facing growing pressure to improve practices and transparency. Tyson Foods has faced criticism and legal action over animal welfare issues, although the company says it is committed to humane handling.[^10]
Some major poultry producers participate in third-party animal welfare auditing programs. For example, Tyson uses the Poultry Care Program of United Egg Producers, which covers worker training, cage-free housing, euthanasia practices, and more.[^11]
However, the full scope of animal welfare standards behind Member‘s Mark chicken is not publicly known. Animal advocates argue that common industry practices like breeding for fast growth and crowded housing are still inhumane.[^12]
Overall, Member‘s Mark chicken seems to meet baseline industry standards, but there‘s room for improvement in terms of transparency and animal welfare guarantees. As consumers pay more attention to these issues, retailers like Sam‘s Club may feel pressure to raise the bar.
More Nuggets of Insight: Chicken Consumption Trends & the Value of Private Label
Considering how popular chicken is in the U.S., the production practices behind brands like Member‘s Mark impact a massive market. Americans consumed an average of 97.6 pounds of chicken per person in 2020, a figure that has steadily risen over the past several decades.[^13] Chicken has now been the top U.S. meat choice over beef and pork since 2015.^14
Several factors drive chicken‘s dominance in the national diet. Its mild flavor and culinary versatility appeal to a wide range of tastes. Many health-conscious consumers choose chicken for its high protein and low fat content. And perhaps most importantly, the industrialization of chicken farming has made it more affordable.
U.S. broiler chicken production has grown by 15% in the past decade, reaching a record high of nearly 45 billion pounds in 2020.^15 Adjusted for inflation, the retail price of chicken has stayed relatively low over this period thanks to efficiency gains from genetics, automation, and vertical integration in the industry.[^16]
Private label chicken brands like Member‘s Mark play an important role in this landscape of ample supply and strong demand. By some estimates, store brands now account for 25% of supermarket meat sales.[^17] Retailers are increasingly investing in private label as a way to provide value, build customer loyalty, and boost margins.[^18]
Chicken is an especially popular category for private label. In 2019, private label captured 26% dollar share and 41% volume share of fresh chicken sales in U.S. supermarkets.^19 Member‘s Mark is a top player in this space thanks to Sam‘s Club‘s wide reach and reputation for quality.
For consumers, private label chicken products offer cost savings without sacrificing taste or safety. In my price surveys, Member‘s Mark chicken often sells for around 20-25% less than name brand equivalents.
Of course, the cheapest way to buy chicken is usually bone-in, skin-on parts that require more home preparation, like leg quarters or split breasts. But private label also makes convenience items more affordable, like boneless skinless breasts, prepackaged wings, and marinated cuts.
Beyond price, I‘ve found that Member‘s Mark chicken performs on par with competitor products in terms of flavor, juiciness, and texture. The broad product lineup means there are options for a wide variety of recipes and preferences.
Conclusions & Caveats: The Bottom Line on Member‘s Mark Chicken
After extensive research and analysis, I believe it‘s highly likely that Member‘s Mark sources much of its chicken from Tyson Foods. While we can‘t definitively confirm this without direct disclosure from Sam‘s Club, Tyson‘s scale, capabilities, and Walmart ties make the company a logical choice.
As the largest U.S. chicken producer, Tyson Foods has the operational sophistication to provide high volumes of chicken that meet Member‘s Mark quality standards and labeling requirements. The company‘s recent moves to expand antibiotic-free production align with Member‘s Mark brand attributes.
However, my investigation also revealed areas where Sam‘s Club and its suppliers could improve in terms of transparency and sustainability. Animal welfare in the chicken industry remains a concern for many consumers, but Member‘s Mark does not provide detailed information on these practices.
Environmental issues like water pollution and waste management are other pain points for large-scale chicken producers. Tyson Foods has faced pressure from advocacy groups to reduce its environmental footprint.[^20] Retailers like Sam‘s Club will likely need to engage more on these fronts to meet changing customer expectations.
Despite these caveats, I believe Member‘s Mark chicken still offers compelling value and quality. Private label meat remains a powerful tool for retailers to serve customers at lower price points. In an era of rising food costs and health concerns, affordable chicken options play an important role.
As a retail industry analyst, I‘ll be closely watching to see how Member‘s Mark and other store brands adapt to evolving consumer demands around transparency and sustainability in the meat supply chain. Customers will likely keep flocking to Member‘s Mark chicken for its combination of quality, variety, and value. But as shoppers dig deeper into how their food is made, retailers will have to proactively tell that story.
[^1]: National Chicken Council. "Broiler Chicken Industry Key Facts 2020."[^2]: Tyson Foods Investor Relations. "Fiscal 2020 Fact Book."
[^3]: Tyson Foods. "Financial Reports – Annual Reports."
[^4]: Piplovic, D. "How Walmart Benefits From Its Relationship With Tyson Foods." Market Realist, Oct 3, 2019.
[^5]: Tyson Foods. "Tyson Foods Delivers on Commitment to No Antibiotics Ever Chicken." Jun 20, 2019.
[^6]: USDA FSIS. "Meat and Poultry Labeling Terms."
[^7]: Poultry Science. "Broiler Chicken Nutrition."
[^8]: USDA Agricultural Marketing Service. "Poultry Programs."
[^9]: National Chicken Council. "Animal Welfare for Broiler Chickens."
[^10]: Barrett, R. "Tyson Foods Faces New Legal Trouble Over Chicken Prices." Forbes, Jun 27, 2020.
[^11]: United Egg Producers. "Animal Husbandry Guidelines for U.S. Egg-Laying Flocks."
[^12]: The Humane League. "The Truth About the Chicken Industry."
[^13]: National Chicken Council. "Per Capita Consumption of Poultry and Livestock." [^16]: USDA Economic Research Service. "Retail Prices for Beef, Pork, and Poultry."
[^17]: The Power of Meat. "An In-Depth Look at Meat Through the Shoppers‘ Eyes, 2021."
[^18]: Weins, M. "Celebrating Private Brands." Supermarket News, Feb 4, 2020. [^20]: Mighty Earth. "New Report Reveals Leading Meat and Dairy Corporations Emit More Emissions Than ExxonMobil."
