Is Walmart a Franchise? Examining the Retail Titan‘s Business Model

Walmart is a name that needs no introduction. With over 10,500 stores spanning 24 countries, the retail giant has become synonymous with low prices, wide selection, and one-stop shopping convenience. Walmart‘s incredible scale and influence have reshaped entire industries and communities over the past six decades.

Content Navigation show

However, many shoppers may not fully understand how Walmart‘s business really works. A common question is whether Walmart stores are independently owned franchises or part of a centralized corporation. As a retail industry analyst and consumer advocate, I‘ve studied Walmart‘s business model extensively. In this article, I‘ll provide a comprehensive look at Walmart‘s corporate structure, ownership, and growth strategy to definitively answer the question: is Walmart a franchise?

Walmart‘s Corporate Structure: A Centralized Model

First, let‘s clarify what it means to be a franchise business. In a franchise model, a corporate brand owner (the franchisor) licenses its trademarks, products, and business systems to independent local operators (the franchisees). The franchisees pay an initial fee and ongoing royalties for the right to use the brand and sell its products. The franchisor provides support and exercises some control, but each franchise location is ultimately a separate business owned by the franchisee.

This is not how Walmart operates. All Walmart stores are corporate-owned, meaning they are direct extensions of Walmart Inc. rather than independent businesses. Walmart does not franchise its brand or business model to third-party operators. Instead, the company manages all of its stores through a centralized corporate hierarchy.

At the top of Walmart‘s organizational structure is a board of directors responsible for overall governance and strategy. Below the board is an executive leadership team that includes the CEO and other C-suite officers in charge of key corporate functions like finance, technology, and human resources. This central management team sets the strategic direction and operational policies for the entire enterprise.

Walmart‘s stores are organized into three major operating segments:

Walmart U.S. – This is Walmart‘s core retail business in the United States, consisting of Supercenters, Discount Stores, Neighborhood Markets, and online operations. Walmart U.S. accounted for 66% of the company‘s total revenue in fiscal 2022.
Sam‘s Club – Sam‘s Club is Walmart‘s membership-based warehouse store format, similar to Costco. Sam‘s Club locations sell bulk goods to both individual and business customers. This segment generated 12% of Walmart‘s FY2022 revenue.
Walmart International – This segment includes all of Walmart‘s retail operations outside of the U.S., spanning countries like Mexico, Canada, China, and South Africa. Walmart International brought in the remaining 22% of the company‘s FY2022 revenue.

Walmart Revenue by Operating Segment, Fiscal Year 2022. Source: Walmart Inc. SEC Filings

Within these segments, Walmart employs a "field" organizational structure to manage its stores. Each store is led by a salaried manager and team of assistant managers responsible for overseeing department supervisors and front-line associates. Stores are clustered into geographic markets and regions for operational oversight and support.

Walmart store managers are given some autonomy to make decisions based on local conditions, but major policies, processes, and strategic initiatives are driven from the home office in Bentonville, Arkansas. Walmart‘s senior leadership team sets the overall direction and store managers are responsible for executing it. This centralized approach allows Walmart to achieve a high degree of standardization and consistency across its massive store footprint.

Who Owns Walmart?

Another key difference between Walmart and a franchise business is its ownership structure. Walmart is a publicly traded corporation, which means it is owned by a diverse group of shareholders who purchase equity in the company through the stock market. Walmart trades on the New York Stock Exchange under the ticker symbol WMT.

Walmart currently has approximately 2.8 billion shares of common stock outstanding. As of March 2022, Walmart‘s 10 largest shareholders were:

The Vanguard Group, Inc. (7.52%)
State Street Corporation (4.69%)
BlackRock Institutional Trust Company, N.A. (4.35%)
Walton Family Holdings Trust (3.34%)
Geode Capital Management, LLC (1.59%)
Walton Enterprises, LLC (1.45%)
Northern Trust Corporation (1.19%)
Norges Bank Investment Management (0.96%)
Bank of America Corporation (0.92%)
JPMorgan Chase & Co. (0.90%)

As you can see, the majority of Walmart‘s shares are held by institutional investors like mutual fund companies, pension funds, and asset managers. However, the Walton family still controls a significant portion of the company‘s equity. Walmart was founded by Sam Walton in 1962, and his heirs remain heavily involved in the business today.

According to Walmart‘s 2022 proxy statement, the Walton family owns approximately 50% of the company‘s total shares outstanding. This includes both direct ownership by individual family members and indirect holdings through various trusts and holding companies. The Waltons‘ majority ownership stake gives them effective control over major corporate decisions and board of director elections.

While the Walton family maintains a strong influence over Walmart, there are thousands of individual shareholders who own the other half of the company. Walmart‘s widespread public ownership means that anyone can buy a stake in the company‘s financial performance and growth prospects.

Walmart‘s Competitive Advantages

Walmart‘s centralized, corporate-owned structure is a key factor behind the company‘s incredible efficiency and profitability. By operating as a single, cohesive entity rather than a network of independent franchisees, Walmart can leverage its massive scale to drive costs down and maintain a competitive advantage.

One of Walmart‘s biggest strengths is its sophisticated supply chain and distribution network. The company operates over 200 distribution centers across the U.S. that use cutting-edge technology to keep stores stocked with the right products at the right time. Walmart‘s size allows it to invest in state-of-the-art logistics infrastructure that smaller retailers simply can‘t match.

Walmart also has tremendous bargaining power with suppliers due to the sheer volume of goods it purchases. The company is the largest customer for many major consumer brands, which gives Walmart significant leverage to negotiate lower prices and better terms. These savings are passed on to shoppers in the form of Walmart‘s "everyday low prices."

Another advantage of Walmart‘s corporate model is the ability to make decisions quickly and implement changes across the entire organization. With a franchise model, each individual owner would need to be convinced to adopt new initiatives, which could slow down progress. Walmart‘s leadership team can roll out new strategies, technologies, and operational improvements to all 10,500 stores simultaneously.

Of course, this centralized approach also has some drawbacks. Walmart has faced criticism over the years for its strict corporate policies and lack of local autonomy. Some argue that Walmart‘s "one size fits all" model doesn‘t always meet the needs of individual communities. Franchise advocates say that locally-owned businesses are more responsive and engaged with their neighborhoods.

However, it‘s hard to argue with Walmart‘s results. The company generated over $570 billion in revenue in fiscal 2022, with a net profit of $13.9 billion. Walmart‘s U.S. stores averaged $430 in sales per square foot, higher than many of its big-box retail peers. The company‘s massive scale and ruthless efficiency have made it one of the most successful and influential businesses in history.

Why Walmart Hasn‘t Franchised

Given the popularity of franchising in the retail industry, you might wonder why Walmart has never adopted this model for growth. Many other large retailers like supermarkets, convenience stores, and fast food chains use franchising to rapidly expand their store counts and geographic footprints.

There are a few key reasons why Walmart has remained committed to a corporate-owned structure:

Control – Walmart‘s business model is built on standardization and consistency across all stores. The company wants customers to have the same experience whether they‘re shopping at a Supercenter in Seattle or a Neighborhood Market in Miami. Franchising would require giving up control to individual owners who might have their own ideas about how to run things.
Profitability – Walmart‘s margins are notoriously thin, often in the low single digits. This is the result of the company‘s aggressive pricing strategy, which is only possible because of its ultra-efficient operations. Adding a layer of franchise fees and royalties could erode Walmart‘s already slim profits.
Complexity – With over 10,500 stores worldwide, managing a franchise network of that scale would be incredibly complex and resource-intensive. Walmart would need to provide support, training, and oversight to thousands of individual franchisees. The company has decided that it‘s more efficient to manage stores directly.
Capital – Walmart has tremendous financial resources and access to capital through the stock and bond markets. The company doesn‘t need franchisees‘ money to fund its growth. In fact, Walmart often prefers to own its real estate outright rather than leasing from landlords.

So while franchising has been a successful model for many retailers, it simply doesn‘t fit with Walmart‘s business philosophy and operating strategy. The company‘s corporate structure is an integral part of its competitive advantage.

Walmart‘s International Challenges

While Walmart‘s U.S. business is incredibly strong, the company has had a more mixed track record with its international operations. Walmart first expanded outside of the U.S. in 1991 with the opening of a Sam‘s Club in Mexico City. Today, the company has a presence in 24 countries around the world.

However, Walmart has struggled in some overseas markets due to cultural differences, regulatory challenges, and strong local competition. In recent years, the company has retreated from several major international markets:

In 2006, Walmart sold its South Korean business to local retailer Shinsegae for $882 million.
In 2016, Walmart sold its Yihaodian e-commerce platform in China to JD.com in exchange for a 5% equity stake.
In 2018, Walmart sold an 80% stake in its Brazilian operations to private equity firm Advent International.
In 2020, Walmart sold its Argentina business to Grupo de Narváez.

Despite these setbacks, Walmart remains committed to international growth in select markets. The company‘s largest overseas business is Walmex, which operates over 2,400 stores in Mexico and Central America. Walmart is also making big bets in India, where it acquired a majority stake in e-commerce leader Flipkart for $16 billion in 2018.

Walmart‘s international strategy is focused on large, high-growth markets where the company can build scale and leverage its core strengths in logistics and supply chain management. The company is also investing heavily in e-commerce and digital capabilities to compete with Amazon and other online retailers.

Looking Ahead: Walmart‘s Future

As the world‘s largest retailer by revenue, Walmart is well-positioned to continue its dominance of the global retail landscape. However, the company faces intense competition and rapid changes in consumer behavior. To stay ahead, Walmart is investing in several key growth areas:

E-commerce – Walmart is aggressively expanding its online business to keep pace with Amazon. The company offers free two-day shipping on millions of items and same-day grocery delivery from over 3,000 stores. Walmart‘s U.S. e-commerce sales grew 79% in fiscal 2021.
Healthcare – Walmart is making a big push into the $3.8 trillion U.S. healthcare industry with its growing network of low-cost health clinics and pharmacies. The company aims to use its scale and efficiency to make healthcare more affordable and accessible for everyday Americans.
Advertising – Walmart is building a fast-growing advertising business that allows brands to reach its massive customer base. Walmart Connect, the company‘s in-house media network, uses valuable first-party shopper data to target ads across Walmart.com and other digital channels.
Membership – Walmart is investing in its subscription services to build deeper relationships with customers. The company‘s Walmart+ membership program offers free shipping, fuel discounts, and mobile scan-and-go shopping for an annual fee of $98.

Of course, Walmart will also face challenges in the years ahead. The company must navigate rising labor costs, supply chain disruptions, and increasing scrutiny from regulators and activists. Walmart‘s size and market power have made it a frequent target of criticism over issues like wages, environmental impact, and foreign sourcing.

However, Walmart has shown an ability to adapt and evolve throughout its history. The company‘s relentless focus on efficiency, innovation, and customer value has allowed it to thrive in an intensely competitive industry. As long as Walmart stays true to its core strengths, it is well-equipped to handle whatever challenges the future may bring.

Conclusion: Walmart Is Not a Franchise

To sum up, Walmart is not a franchise business. It is a publicly traded corporation that owns and operates all of its stores directly. Walmart‘s centralized structure and strict operational control are key to its ability to offer low prices and a consistent customer experience across a massive global footprint.

While the Walton family remains Walmart‘s largest shareholder, the company is owned by a broad base of institutional and individual investors. Walmart‘s stock is traded on public exchanges, which allows anyone to buy a piece of the company‘s financial success.

Walmart‘s decision not to franchise reflects its unique business model and competitive position. Franchising would add complexity and cost to an organization that is already finely tuned for efficiency and scale. Walmart‘s corporate structure is an integral part of its identity and success.

Whether you‘re a Walmart shopper, employee, supplier, or investor, understanding the company‘s business model is essential. Walmart‘s size and influence make it a major force in the global economy and a bellwether for the retail industry. As Walmart goes, so goes the world of consumer commerce.