As a savvy shopper and student of the retail industry, you‘ve likely spent time browsing the aisles at Target. With its signature red bullseye logo, trendy product assortment, and convenient locations, Target has become a go-to destination for millions of consumers looking to check off their shopping lists. But have you ever stopped to consider how Target stores come to be? Is Target a franchise opportunity for enterprising business owners, or something else entirely?
As a retail industry expert and discerning consumer myself, I set out to answer this common question about one of America‘s largest and most influential companies. What I found is that while Target shares some characteristics with franchised businesses, the company is structured as a traditional C-corporation with a centralized ownership and operating model. In this article, I‘ll take you on a deep dive into Target‘s business fundamentals and explain the key factors that have shaped the company‘s growth strategy over time.
Target by the Numbers: A Retail Powerhouse
Before we examine Target‘s organizational DNA, it‘s worth sizing up the company‘s scale and impact as a retailer. Target is nothing short of a behemoth in the U.S. consumer economy, with some eye-popping statistics to match:
- Annual Revenue: For fiscal year 2022, Target recorded total revenue of $106 billion, putting it in the upper echelon of U.S. companies.
- Store Footprint: As of early 2023, Target operates 1,948 stores across all 50 U.S. states, with a presence in 98 of the top 100 U.S. markets.
- Workforce: Target employs over 450,000 people in stores, distribution centers, and headquarters roles, making it one of the largest private employers in the U.S.
- E-Commerce Sales: Target‘s digital sales reached $19.8 billion in 2022, accounting for 20% of the company‘s total revenue and growing at a rapid clip.
These high-level numbers paint a picture of a thriving, nationally-scaled retail chain with deep roots in American communities. So how did Target achieve this level of reach and influence? The answer lies in the company‘s corporate structure and growth strategy.
Target‘s Corporate DNA
Target is organized as a C-corporation, which is a specific type of legal structure for a business. In a C-corp, the company is owned by shareholders and managed by a board of directors and executive team. This is different from other common business structures like sole proprietorships, partnerships, or LLCs.
Some key features of Target‘s corporate structure include:
-
Centralized ownership: All Target stores are fully owned and operated by Target Corporation. The company does not franchise or license its brand or business model to independent owner-operators.
-
Corporate governance: Target is governed by a board of directors who are elected by shareholders. The board is responsible for overseeing the company‘s strategy, risk management, and financial performance.
-
Public stock listing: Target has been a publicly-traded company since 1967. Its stock trades under the ticker symbol TGT on the New York Stock Exchange, allowing individuals and institutions to own a piece of the company.
-
Professional management: Target employs a deep bench of professional managers and executives to oversee every aspect of the business. This includes functions like merchandising, supply chain, store operations, marketing, finance, and human resources.
So why did Target‘s founders choose a corporate structure over other models like franchising? There are several potential reasons:
Control: As a corporation, Target can maintain tight control over its brand identity, customer experience, and operating standards. The company doesn‘t have to rely on individual franchisees to uphold its vision and values.
Capabilities: Target‘s corporate structure allows it to build world-class capabilities in areas like supply chain, technology, and marketing that span the entire enterprise. A franchise model would make it harder to achieve this level of coordination and consistency.
Capital: As a large, profitable corporation, Target has access to significant financial resources through its balance sheet and equity market. It doesn‘t need franchisees to provide capital for expansion.
These factors have allowed Target to grow and thrive as a corporation, even as other retailers have experimented with alternative models.
Target‘s Growth Strategy
Target‘s growth over time has been fueled by a combination of organic expansion, strategic acquisitions, and business model innovation. Let‘s take a closer look at each of these drivers:
Store expansion: For much of its history, Target‘s primary growth engine was opening new stores in untapped markets. The company followed a hub-and-spoke model, establishing large distribution centers in key regions and then filling in the surrounding area with stores. This allowed Target to efficiently serve a wide geographic footprint and achieve economies of scale.
Acquisitions: While Target has done the majority of its growth organically, the company has made some notable acquisitions over the years. These include Marshall Field‘s department stores in 1990 and Mervyn‘s discount stores in 1978. More recently, Target has acquired digital-native brands like Shipt and Grand Junction to boost its e-commerce capabilities.
Business model innovation: In addition to expanding its physical footprint, Target has also innovated its business model to drive growth. Some key examples include:
- Launching new store formats like small-format urban stores and college campus locations
- Developing a robust private label program with over 45 exclusive brands
- Investing heavily in e-commerce and omnichannel capabilities like same-day delivery and curbside pickup
- Partnering with high-profile designers and influencers on limited-time product collaborations
By diversifying its growth levers and continuously evolving its business model, Target has been able to thrive in a rapidly-changing retail landscape.
Target‘s Competitive Positioning
One of the keys to Target‘s success has been its unique competitive positioning in the retail sector. While Target is often compared to other large discount chains like Walmart or dollar stores, the company has carved out a differentiated niche in the market.
Specifically, Target aims to offer a "cheap chic" shopping experience that combines the affordability and convenience of a big box store with the style and quality of a department store. This is reflected in Target‘s:
-
Product assortment: Target offers a mix of national brands and trendy private label products at competitive prices. The company is known for collaborating with high-end designers to create affordable, limited-edition collections.
-
Store experience: Target stores are known for being clean, well-organized, and easy to navigate. The company invests in store design and visual merchandising to create an inviting shopping environment.
-
Marketing: Target‘s marketing emphasizes style, fashion, and aspirational lifestyle imagery. The company‘s iconic "Expect More, Pay Less" slogan encapsulates its value proposition.
By occupying this middle ground between discount and upscale retail, Target has been able to differentiate itself from competitors and build a loyal customer base.
The Franchising Alternative
While Target has thrived as a corporation, it‘s worth considering how the company might have fared if it had chosen to franchise its business instead. Franchising is a popular growth model in the retail and service sectors, particularly for businesses with strong brands and repeatable operating models.
Under a franchise model, Target would have licensed its brand, products, and operating system to independent owner-operators in exchange for an initial franchise fee and ongoing royalty payments. Franchisees would have been responsible for building and running their own stores according to Target‘s standards.
Some potential benefits of franchising for Target could have included:
-
Faster growth: Franchising can allow a company to expand more quickly by tapping into the capital and entrepreneurial drive of franchisees. Target might have been able to open stores in new markets faster than it could on its own.
-
Local expertise: Franchisees often have deep roots in their local communities and can bring valuable market knowledge and relationships to the table. This could have helped Target tailor its assortment and marketing to local tastes.
-
Reduced risk: By shifting some of the financial and operational risk to franchisees, Target could have insulated itself from the ups and downs of individual store performance.
However, there are also significant drawbacks to franchising that likely factored into Target‘s decision to remain a corporation:
-
Loss of control: Franchising requires a company to give up some degree of control over its brand and operations. Target would have had to rely on franchisees to uphold its standards and represent its values.
-
Complexity: Managing a network of franchisees can be complex and time-consuming. Target would have had to invest in systems and support infrastructure to onboard, train, and monitor franchisees.
-
Conflict: Franchising can create misaligned incentives between the franchisor and franchisees. Disputes over issues like royalty rates, territorial rights, and operating standards are common in franchise systems.
Ultimately, Target‘s leadership likely decided that the benefits of franchising were outweighed by the risks and complexity. By remaining a corporation, Target has been able to maintain control over its brand and operations while still achieving significant growth and scale.
Looking Ahead
As Target looks to the future, the company is well-positioned to continue its growth trajectory as a corporation. With a strong brand, loyal customer base, and proven business model, Target has the foundation in place to thrive in the evolving retail landscape.
Some key opportunities and challenges that Target will likely face in the coming years include:
-
E-commerce growth: Target‘s digital business has been growing rapidly, but the company still lags behind Amazon and Walmart in online market share. Continuing to invest in its e-commerce capabilities and omnichannel offerings will be critical for Target‘s long-term success.
-
Supply chain optimization: As Target‘s business becomes increasingly complex and global, the company will need to continually optimize its supply chain to ensure product availability, speed to market, and cost efficiency.
-
Store format innovation: While Target has been successful with its small-format urban stores, there may be additional opportunities to tailor its store formats to specific customer segments or shopping occasions.
-
Private label expansion: Target‘s private label brands have been a key differentiator and growth driver for the company. Continuing to develop and market exclusive products that resonate with customers will be important for driving loyalty and margin.
-
International expansion: To date, Target‘s business has been almost entirely focused on the U.S. market. While international expansion would come with significant challenges, it could provide a new avenue for growth in the future.
By continuing to innovate and evolve within its corporate structure, Target has the potential to build on its legacy as one of America‘s most successful and influential retailers.
Conclusion
So, is Target a franchise? The simple answer is no – but the reality is far more nuanced and interesting. Target‘s story is one of a company that has charted its own path to success by staying true to its core values and competencies.
While franchising has fueled the growth of many iconic American brands, it‘s not the right model for every business. For Target, remaining a corporation has allowed the company to maintain control over its brand, culture, and operations while still achieving massive scale and market share.
As a student of retail and a Target shopper myself, I‘ve long admired the company‘s unique approach to its business. By combining the best elements of discount and upscale retail, Target has carved out a beloved niche in the hearts and minds of consumers. And by remaining a corporation, the company has been able to innovate and evolve in ways that might have been harder as a franchise.
Of course, no business model is perfect, and Target will face its share of challenges and opportunities in the years ahead. But with a strong foundation, agile leadership, and customer-centric culture, I believe Target is well-equipped to thrive as a corporation for generations to come. The next time you find yourself browsing the bright, inviting aisles of your local Target store, take a moment to appreciate the unique business behind the bullseye – and the power of charting your own path in the world of retail.
