As a diligent consumer and vehicle owner, you know that the choices you make at the pump can have a big impact on your engine‘s long-term health and performance. With so many options out there, it can be a challenge to navigate which gas stations and brands are really worth your hard-earned dollar.
One retailer you might encounter if you live in the Midwest is Meijer, a supercenter chain that‘s expanded its footprint in the fuel business over the last few decades. Meijer gas stations are known for their competitive prices, but many customers wonder – is the gas actually high quality? Specifically, does it meet the coveted "Top Tier" standard?
In this comprehensive guide, we‘ll dive into the nitty gritty details of Meijer‘s gas quality and compare it to other major brands. We‘ll also provide expert tips and insights to help you make more informed decisions at the pump. Let‘s get started!
The Importance of Choosing Quality Gas
Before we analyze Meijer gas, let‘s talk about why fuel quality matters in the first place. According to the U.S. Energy Information Administration, the average American household spends nearly $3,000 per year on gasoline. With gas prices constantly fluctuating, it‘s understandable that drivers want to seek out the cheapest option.
However, choosing the cheapest gas could end up costing you more in the long run if it leads to engine issues, reduced fuel economy, or even expensive repairs. The EPA requires a minimum level of detergent additives in all gas, but many experts argue it‘s not sufficient for optimal engine cleanliness.
"Using gas with insufficient detergent additives can cause carbon deposit buildup, which can lead to poor fuel economy, acceleration hesitation, increased emissions, and other drivability issues," says John Ibbotson, Chief Automotive Services Manager at CR. "Over time, this can lead to costly repairs like having to replace fuel injectors or intake valves."
The good news is there are ways to identify higher quality gas that goes beyond the minimum standards. One of the most recognized designations is the "Top Tier" label.
What Does "Top Tier" Gas Really Mean?
Top Tier is a trademarked fuel standard developed in 2004 by a group of major automakers including General Motors, Honda, Toyota, Volkswagen, Audi, and BMW. These companies were concerned that the EPA standards for detergent additives were not adequate to maintain optimal engine performance in newer vehicles.
To earn the Top Tier label, a gasoline brand must meet certain criteria:
- Contain 2-3x the cleaning agents compared to the EPA minimum
- Undergo rigorous third-party testing to prove effectiveness
- Maintain the enhanced detergency in all grades of fuel (not just premium)
Currently, there are 48 retail brands that participate in the Top Tier program, representing about one-third of gas stations in the U.S. Some of the most prominent Top Tier brands include Shell, Mobil, Chevron, BP, and Costco.
"AAA found that non-Top Tier gasolines caused 19 times more engine deposits than Top Tier brands after just 4,000 miles of simulated driving," according to AAA‘s manager of Automotive Engineering, Megan McKernan.
Using gas without sufficient detergent can lead to a 2-4% reduction in fuel economy, or up to $100 in additional fuel costs per year for the average driver, AAA reports. So while Top Tier gas may cost a few extra cents per gallon, it can pay for itself by keeping your engine cleaner and more efficient in the long run.
The History of Meijer Gas Stations
Now that we understand the importance of Top Tier gas, let‘s take a closer look at Meijer as a fuel retailer. Meijer is a family-owned supercenter chain that operates over 250 stores across six Midwestern states. The company has come a long way since its humble beginnings as a small grocery store in Greenville, Michigan in 1934.
In the 1960s, Meijer was an early pioneer of the "one-stop shopping" concept, opening the first "supercenter" store that combined groceries and department store items. As the company expanded over the following decades, they began opening their own gas stations at select locations in the 1990s.
Today, Meijer is one of the largest privately-owned retailers in the country with estimated annual sales of over $16 billion. The company is consistently ranked as a top regional gas brand by market research firms like GasBuddy and Market Force.
While Meijer may not have the same brand recognition as a fuel retailer compared to the likes of Shell or Mobil, they‘ve grown to become a major player in the Midwest. Meijer gas stations are known for matching or beating competitor prices in the area, making them an attractive choice for price-sensitive shoppers.
Meijer‘s Commitment to Top Tier Gas
So Meijer definitely has competitive prices, but is the gas actually good? The quick answer is yes, Meijer is a licensed Top Tier gasoline brand. This means all grades of Meijer gas meet the stringent Top Tier detergency standards to prevent engine buildup.
However, Meijer gas hasn‘t always been Top Tier certified. Prior to 2016, the company used an enhanced additive package but didn‘t quite meet the Top Tier threshold. But in October 2016, Meijer announced a partnership with a major fuel supplier to provide Top Tier gas at all locations.
"As a retailer that sells top-tier gasoline, we are able to offer our customers a premium product at a tremendous value," said Rick Keyes, President and CEO of Meijer, in a press release. "Meijer customers don‘t have to shop around for this quality fuel because we have it at every Meijer station."
The move to Top Tier was a smart one for Meijer. A 2016 AAA survey found that 75% of U.S. drivers believe there are differences in quality of gas sold by different retailers, and one-third choose a gas station based on whether it has additives to help clean their engine.
While Meijer has always promoted its gas for having "quality additives for optimum performance," the Top Tier designation provides a recognizable seal of approval beyond just marketing claims. It shows a commitment to meeting an industry-leading standard for fuel quality.
Putting Meijer Gas to the Test
Of course, seeing the Top Tier label on a pump is one thing, but how does Meijer gas actually perform in real-world conditions? Since Top Tier is a trademarked standard, you can rest assured that all licensed retailers have been rigorously tested for deposit control and engine cleanliness.
However, there have been a few additional independent studies that have put Meijer gas specifically to the test. In 2017, the Petroleum Quality Institute of America (PQIA) ran lab and field tests on Meijer‘s 87 octane regular gas taken from multiple locations.
The results? Meijer gas samples passed all PQIA tests for quality and consistency. The gas matched the advertised octane level and contained the proper additives for a Top Tier licensed fuel. This is an important distinction, as some discount or unbranded stations have been found to have inconsistent additive levels even if they meet EPA minimums.
It‘s worth noting that Meijer gas, like most other Top Tier retailers, is considered a "base" Top Tier fuel. This means it has enhanced detergency compared to non-Top Tier brands, but doesn‘t have a specialized formula or huge marketing campaign behind it like Shell V-Power Nitro+ or Chevron with Techron.
If you‘re looking for the absolute latest and greatest fuel technology, you may want to splurge on one of these "premium" Top Tier options with extra additives. But if you just want a reliable, high-quality gas at an affordable price, Meijer fits the bill perfectly.
Comparing Meijer Gas Prices to Competitors
Speaking of price, let‘s talk dollars and cents. After all, as much as fuel quality matters, most of us still have a budget to stick to. The good news is that Meijer gas is consistently among the cheapest in the areas where they operate.
According to GasBuddy data from July 2021, Meijer has the lowest average gas prices in 5 out of the 6 states where it has gas stations, including:
- Michigan: $3.05/gal (vs. $3.18 statewide avg.)
- Indiana: $2.97/gal (vs. $3.03 statewide avg.)
- Illinois: $3.17/gal (vs. $3.26 statewide avg.)
- Ohio: $2.99/gal (vs. $3.05 statewide avg.)
- Kentucky: $2.93/gal (vs. $2.96 statewide avg.)
The only state where Meijer doesn‘t have the cheapest average price is Wisconsin at $2.94/gal (vs. $2.89 statewide avg.) But even there, it‘s only 5 cents above the average and still cheaper than many other Top Tier brands.
Here‘s how Meijer stacks up against other Top Tier retailers on average price in the Midwest region as of July 2021, according to GasBuddy:
| Retailer | Price/Gal. |
|---|---|
| Circle K | $3.18 |
| Shell | $3.16 |
| BP | $3.08 |
| Mobil | $3.05 |
| Costco | $2.99 |
| Meijer | $2.98 |
| Sam‘s Club | $2.96 |
As you can see, Meijer beats out many of the biggest names in the business on price, while offering the same Top Tier fuel quality. The only retailers consistently cheaper are warehouse clubs like Costco and Sam‘s Club, which usually require a membership.
On top of the already competitive base prices, Meijer offers several ways to save even more at the pump. These include:
- Meijer Credit Card: Save 10 cents/gal when you spend $75 or more at Meijer stores
- mPerks Rewards: Earn points on gas and grocery purchases for exclusive savings
- Meijer Fleet Card: Business customers can save up to 6 cents/gal with volume discounts
The Bottom Line: Is Meijer Gas Worth It?
After taking an in-depth look at Meijer‘s fuel quality, Top Tier standards, pricing, and rewards programs, we can confidently conclude that Meijer gas is an excellent choice overall. You can enjoy the benefits of enhanced engine protection without overpaying at the pump.
While Meijer may not be a household name nationwide, they‘ve proven to be a major player in the Midwestern gas retail market. Their commitment to Top Tier certification and highly competitive pricing make them a top choice for savvy shoppers who prioritize both quality and value.
"Drivers can be confident that gas sold at Top Tier licensed retailers like Meijer will help keep their vehicle‘s engine running clean and efficiently," says John Eichberger, Executive Director of the Fuels Institute. "While the price difference may be negligible, the long-term benefits of using a higher quality fuel are worth it."
Of course, price and quality specs are just one part of the equation – convenience and availability also play a role in deciding where to fill up. Luckily, Meijer has over 200 gas station locations across the Midwest so you won‘t have to drive far to find one. The supercenters are also great for knocking out grocery shopping and gas fill-ups in the same stop.
In summary, don‘t sleep on Meijer gas just because it doesn‘t have a flashy national ad campaign. All the data and testing we‘ve analyzed point to it being a top-notch choice for the discerning consumer. Your wallet will thank you in the short term and your engine will thank you for thousands of miles to come.
