The Ultimate Guide to Dealing with a Lost USPS Tracking Number

As an experienced e-commerce manager and avid online shopper, I know all too well the sinking feeling that comes with realizing you‘ve lost an important USPS tracking number. Whether you‘re a seller shipping an item or a customer eagerly awaiting a package, not having that tracking information can make you feel totally helpless and frustrated.

Content Navigation show

But don‘t despair! While losing a tracking number is undoubtedly stressful, you‘re not out of options yet. In this comprehensive guide, I‘ll walk you through exactly what to do if you find yourself in this scenario and provide actionable tips to ensure you never lose a critical tracking number again.

Just How Common Is It to Lose a USPS Tracking Number?

First, some context on the scope of this problem. The United States Postal Service is a massive operation, processing and delivering an astonishing volume of mail each and every day. According to the USPS website, in 2020 alone, the Postal Service:

  • Processed and delivered 129.2 billion pieces of mail
  • Handled 7.3 billion packages (a 40% jump over 2019 due to the pandemic e-commerce boom)
  • Managed 1.7 billion Priority Mail and Priority Mail Express items that come with USPS Tracking

When you‘re dealing with numbers on such a massive scale, it‘s sadly inevitable that a small percentage of those tracking numbers will get lost by senders or receivers each year. In fact, it may even be more common than you think.

Unfortunately, the USPS doesn‘t provide public data on exactly how many tracking numbers they estimate are lost each year. But if even a tiny 0.5% of those nearly 2 billion Priority Mail packages had a lost tracking number, that would amount to nearly 10 million instances. It really puts the sheer volume in perspective!

The Consequences of Losing Your USPS Tracking Number

Okay, so we‘ve established that losing a USPS tracking number is fairly common, even if the USPS doesn‘t openly talk about it. But what are the actual stakes and potential fallout of not having that tracking information for your package? Here are a few of the most common issues:

  1. Not being able to verify your package was delivered. Without a tracking number to reference, you have no surefire way to confirm your parcel made it all the way to the final destination. This uncertainty can be maddening, especially if you‘re sending something important like legal documents or a high-value item.

  2. Increased risk of your package being lost for good. While the vast majority of untracked mail does eventually make it to its destination, a missing tracking number increases the odds of your package being truly lost and never making it to the recipient. On average, the USPS processes around 146,000 missing mail searches each year.

  3. Unable to file an insurance claim if needed. For certain Priority Mail shipments, you may have the option of purchasing additional shipping insurance to protect yourself financially in case the package is lost or damaged. However, if you don‘t have the tracking number, it will be difficult to provide evidence to file a successful insurance claim with USPS.

  4. Difficult to prove the item was shipped for online sellers. If you‘re an e-commerce seller shipping an item to a customer, losing the tracking number can open you up to fraud and chargebacks. For example, if the buyer claims they never received the package, without tracking info you may have a harder time proving the item was in fact shipped.

  5. Frustrated customers wondering where their order is. Even if the package does ultimately get delivered, a lost tracking number means the recipient has no idea where it is while en route or when to expect final delivery. If you‘re a business owner, this can lead to unhappy customers, bad reviews, and lost future sales.

As you can see, while losing a tracking number isn‘t the end of the world, it‘s still a major headache that can snowball into bigger problems if not dealt with swiftly. So what can you do about it? Read on for a full action plan.

Step 1: Thoroughly Check All Possible Locations of Your USPS Tracking Number

Before you officially declare your tracking number as lost, make absolutely sure it‘s not hiding in plain sight. The first step is to systematically check all the common places your tracking info may be recorded:

Places for Senders to Look:

  • USPS sales receipt from the post office (or kiosk)
  • Shipping label on your package
  • Packing list inside the box
  • Online purchase record if you bought postage digitally (via USPS Click-N-Ship, eBay, PayPal, etc.)
  • Your email inbox for an order/shipping confirmation
  • The notes app or photos on your phone (in case you took a picture of the receipt or package)

Places for Recipients to Look:

  • Original order confirmation email from the online merchant
  • Shipping notification email (if provided)
  • Your USPS Informed Delivery dashboard
  • Reaching out directly to the shipper for tracking info

I can‘t stress this enough: be incredibly thorough while checking these sources! I‘ve had so many cases over the years where a customer swore they checked everywhere for their tracking number, only for me to later find it clear as day on their crumpled up receipt or in a dark corner of their email inbox. It happens to the best of us, so don‘t feel bad—just make sure you do your due diligence and triple check.

Step 2: Contact USPS to See If They Can Help You Recover the Number

Let‘s say you completed step 1 and still can‘t find any record of your USPS tracking number. Your next step is to enlist the help of the professionals by contacting USPS directly to explain your situation.

Now, it‘s important to set expectations here. Officially, the USPS states they are unable to retrieve lost tracking information for customers. According to their tracking FAQ:

"USPS Tracking numbers are not reusable and cannot be located by USPS personnel. If you have lost your receipt with your USPS Tracking number, we apologize but we will be unable to provide that information."

However, in my experience, if you can provide enough specific details about your shipment, there‘s a chance a sympathetic post office manager may be able to help. While not guaranteed, it‘s absolutely worth a try as a next resort.

To have the best shot at USPS recovering your number, make sure to have the following info ready to go:

  • Exact date and time you shipped the package
  • Location and name of the post office or kiosk you used
  • Total dollar amount of the shipping charges
  • Type of postage or service used (First Class, Priority, Express, etc.)
  • General description of what the package looks like (dimensions, weight, color, box/envelope type)
  • Your mailing address and the recipient‘s full address
  • Payment details (last 4 digits of card used, or specify if paid in cash)

If you bought postage online or from a self-service kiosk, make that known to the USPS agent, as those transactions may be easier for them to look up after the fact. And if you recall the name of the specific USPS employee who helped you, that‘s worth mentioning too in case they can locate your record under their unique clerk ID number.

It‘s not a sure thing, but I‘ve personally seen USPS managers go above and beyond to pull shipping records and recover a lost tracking number for customers who provide enough details. It never hurts to ask nicely and share how much tracking down this number would mean to you!

Step 3: Contact the Recipient and/or Merchant for Help

If you‘ve tried steps 1 and 2 and still come up empty handed, don‘t forget to enlist the help of the other parties involved in your shipment.

If you‘re the sender, reach out to your recipient via phone, text, or email and ask if they have the tracking information on hand from a shipping notification or online order record. You may even ask them to send you a screenshot of any tracking information they have.

And if you‘re the one receiving the package, your next step is to contact the merchant or sender and request the tracking number. If you ordered from an online store, start by replying to your email order confirmation. You can also look up the company‘s customer service number or support chat feature on their website. If it was a person-to-person shipment, simply call, text or email the sender directly.

The key in any of these interactions is to be calm, polite, and understanding. Getting upset or making demands is only going to slow down the process of recovering your tracking number. Remember, lost numbers are incredibly common—you‘re not the first person to deal with this and the merchant or sender is likely to be understanding.

The Limitations of USPS Tracking (and Why a Lost Number Isn‘t the End of the World)

Even after taking all the steps above, there‘s a chance you still won‘t be able to locate your lost USPS tracking number. While frustrating, it‘s not necessarily a catastrophe.

That‘s because, if we‘re being honest, the USPS‘ tracking system has some inherent limitations—especially compared to private express couriers like FedEx and UPS. Some key differences:

  • Not every single package comes with tracking. With FedEx and UPS, every parcel comes with built-in tracking. With USPS, tracking isn‘t included on certain lower-cost services like regular First-Class Mail (unless you pay for an add-on).

  • Mediocre insurance options. USPS insurance maxes out at $5,000 per package, while FedEx and UPS allow you to insure items up to $50,000 in value. That matters if you‘re trying to file a claim for a lost package.

  • Tracking isn‘t quite as detailed. Compared to FedEx or UPS, USPS scans tend to be less frequent and provide less detailed information about a package‘s location while in transit.

  • Slower to declare a missing package. According to Consumer Reports, FedEx will declare a package lost after 5 days, while UPS will start a search after 24 hours. USPS, however, requires customers wait 7 full days before they‘ll even start an investigation.

The point here isn‘t to shame USPS, as they are often the most affordable option and generally do a great job delivering billions of packages each year. Rather, I mention their system‘s limitations to say that, in the grand scheme of things, a lost tracking number with USPS is not the end of the world.

Yes, not having tracking info is stressful, and it can make you feel helpless. But at the end of the day, the vast majority of USPS packages without tracking do eventually make it to their final destination. Case in point: in Q3 2021, a whopping 93% of USPS shipments were delivered on time (though this number does dip during peak seasons).

So if you‘ve taken the steps above and still can‘t find your tracking number, take a deep breath. Unless you were shipping something truly irreplaceable or time-sensitive, odds are your package will make its way to its final destination eventually. And now that you know how common this issue is, you can take preventative measures in the future.

How to Prevent Losing Another USPS Tracking Number Ever Again

To avoid the headache of losing tracking numbers in the future, I recommend getting in the habit of immediately recording and saving this information the moment you receive it. A little proactivity now can save you a world of stress later.

Strategies for Senders:

  • Snap a photo of your postal receipt and upload it to a searchable cloud service like Google Drive, Dropbox, or Evernote
  • If you print your own labels, save the PDF or image file with the tracking number in the file name
  • Use a shipping software or e-commerce platform that automatically saves your tracking numbers and shipping records

Strategies for Recipients:

  • When you receive an email or text notification with your tracking number, immediately "star" the message or mark it as important so it‘s easier to find later
  • Copy/paste the tracking number itself and email it to yourself with a clear subject line like "[Company Name] Order Tracking Info"
  • Take a screenshot of any tracking details provided and save it to a designated folder on your phone or computer
  • Sign up for USPS Informed Delivery so you have another electronic record of incoming parcels

If you‘re an e-commerce business owner frequently shipping orders, I also can‘t recommend using shipping software enough. Tools like ShipStation, ShippingEasy, and ShipWorks not only streamline your labeling process, but automatically store tracking information for every package you send out. This can be an absolute lifesaver when you have an angry customer claiming their order never arrived.

For those businesses that prefer more of a DIY approach, I‘d suggest, at minimum, keeping a detailed spreadsheet that logs tracking numbers for every shipment that goes out your door. Meticulously maintaining these records is well worth the extra effort if it prevents even one lost package or disputed transaction.

Key Takeaways for Dealing with Lost USPS Tracking Numbers

Alright, that was a lot of information to take in! Let‘s quickly recap the most important points you should remember:

  1. Triple check all possible locations of your tracking number before declaring it lost, including post office receipts, package labels, emails, and phone photos.
  2. Contact USPS customer service or your local post office for help, being prepared with key details about your shipment to help them investigate.
  3. Enlist the recipient and/or merchant who shipped the package to help track down the number as well.
  4. If you still can‘t recover tracking info, don‘t panic. The majority of USPS packages do ultimately get delivered, even if tracking is lost.
  5. Implement proactive strategies like using shipping software and immediately saving tracking info to avoid this scenario in the future.

Hopefully, these tips have given you a clear action plan to deal with a lost tracking number and the confidence to know it‘s not a helpless situation. While USPS‘ system isn‘t perfect, in most cases, your package will make it to its destination safe and sound even without the tracking details.

Have you ever dealt with a lost USPS tracking number? How did you handle it? Let me know in the comments below—I‘d love to hear your experience and any other creative tips you have to add!

Here‘s to less stress and more successful shipments,

[Your Name] E-commerce Operations Manager & Shipping Expert