As a retail and consumer expert, I‘ve seen firsthand how digital payment apps like Venmo have transformed the way we spend, save, and share money. With just a few taps on your phone, you can instantly split a dinner bill, pay your rent, or send a birthday gift to a friend. It‘s no wonder that Venmo processed over $230 billion in transactions last year alone, with 70 million active users in the US.[^1]
But as convenient as Venmo is, it‘s important to remember that every transaction you make leaves a digital trail that can be tracked, stored, and potentially shared with third parties. In this comprehensive guide, I‘ll dive into everything you need to know about your Venmo privacy settings, including:
- What information Venmo collects and how it‘s used
- How to make your past and future transactions private
- What to do if you want to close your Venmo account entirely
- How law enforcement can access your Venmo history
- Tips for maximizing your financial privacy and security on Venmo
Whether you‘re a Venmo veteran or just signed up for an account, this guide will help you take control of your sensitive financial data and make informed choices about what you share on the platform. Let‘s get started!
Venmo‘s Default Privacy Settings Expose User Transactions
When you create a Venmo account, your default privacy setting is "Public." This means that unless you actively change your settings, every transaction you make will be visible to anyone on the internet. That‘s right – complete strangers can scroll through your Venmo feed and see who you‘re paying, when, and often what for (thanks to those emoji-filled payment notes).
A 2018 study found that Venmo‘s public feed API exposed over 200 million transactions from 7 million users, allowing researchers to "quickly identify user actions, relationships, and private details."[^2] This data can be incredibly revealing – imagine a potential employer, landlord, or even a stalker being able to see that you paid for a medical test, bought drinks at a strip club, or sent money to an ex.
Figure 1: Venmo privacy settings and what information is exposed in each one. Source: Venmo
How to Hide Your Venmo Transactions from the Public
Fortunately, Venmo does give users the ability to change their privacy settings and hide their transaction history from prying eyes. Here‘s how to make your account private in a few simple steps:
- Open the Venmo app and tap the "☰" icon in the upper left corner
- Tap "Settings" and then "Privacy"
- Under "Default Privacy Setting," select "Private"
- Toggle off "Appear in Friend Lists" if you don‘t want your profile to be searchable
- Toggle off "Share My Transactions on Facebook" unless you want your Venmo activity cross-posted
It‘s important to note that even if you set your default privacy to "Private", you‘ll still need to go back and manually update any past transactions that were posted publicly. Here‘s how:
- Tap the "☰" icon in the upper left corner and select "Payments"
- Tap on a transaction to expand it
- Tap the privacy setting under the payment (likely listed as "Public")
- Change the privacy setting to "Private" and tap "Save Settings"
- Repeat for each transaction you want to hide
Keep in mind that even with a "Private" setting, Venmo still has a complete record of your transaction details. The company shares some aggregate, anonymized data with third parties for marketing and research purposes.[^3] And as I‘ll cover in a later section, law enforcement can also request access to your Venmo history if they suspect it‘s been used for illegal activity.
What Venmo‘s Privacy Policy Says About Your Data
To really understand how Venmo handles your financial data, it‘s important to dig into the details of their privacy policy. While the full document is over 4,000 words[^4], here are some of the key points that every user should know:
- Venmo collects a wide range of personal information including your name, address, phone number, email, Social Security number, date of birth, bank account and credit card numbers, employment and income information, transaction history, IP address, device identifiers, and social media data
- This data is used to provide the Venmo service, improve the platform, prevent fraud and illegal activity, and send you marketing communications
- Venmo retains your account information and transaction history "as long as necessary for our business purposes or legal requirements" – even if you close your account
- Venmo shares some of your data with PayPal (its parent company), service providers, financial institutions, collection agencies, and law enforcement when required
- Users can request to access and correct certain personal information that Venmo has collected by contacting their support team
It can be unnerving to realize just how much sensitive data Venmo has access to and how long they hold onto it. As Gennie Gebhart, Acting Activism Director at the Electronic Frontier Foundation explains:
"Financial data is some of the most sensitive information there is about you. There are very few things that feel more invasive than having vast amounts of data about your financial transactions and ties collected and retained for long periods of time, especially when that collection is incidental to or unnecessary for the service you thought you were using."[^5]
If reading Venmo‘s privacy policy makes you uncomfortable, you‘re not alone. A 2020 Consumer Reports survey found that 69% of Americans are concerned about their data privacy, and 96% think more should be done to protect it.[^6]
Figure 2: Percentage of Americans concerned about data privacy in various sectors. Source: Consumer Reports
How Law Enforcement Uses Venmo Data to Solve Crimes
As convenient as payment apps are for the average consumer, they‘ve also become a valuable tool for law enforcement looking to track down criminals. Because Venmo maintains detailed records of all transactions (even those made privately), police can subpoena this data during an investigation to establish timelines, relationships between suspects, and potential motives.
Some high-profile examples of Venmo records being used in criminal cases include:
-
The Capital One Hacker: Paige Thompson was accused of hacking into Capital One‘s network and stealing data on over 100 million customers in 2019. Law enforcement searched Thompson‘s Venmo history and discovered payments she received that were likely related to stolen data, including one with the note: "Go on girl, get that money and get some more servers with those profits."[^7]
-
The Fyre Festival Fraud: Billy McFarland, creator of the infamous Fyre Festival scam, left a trail of Venmo transactions revealing how he blew investor funds on personal expenses like yacht rentals, private flights, and luxury villas. Prosecutors used McFarland‘s Venmo history to prove he misrepresented the festival‘s financials and lied to investors.[^8]
-
The Capitol Riot Investigation: After the January 6th attack on the US Capitol, law enforcement obtained Venmo records to prove connections between some rioters and organizers of Stop the Steal rallies. One payment showed a Proud Boys member sending $250 to another member with the note "Travel expenses for upcoming Patriot Events."[^9]
According to Venmo‘s Law Enforcement Guidelines, the company requires a subpoena, court order, or search warrant before disclosing customer records. However, they will provide basic account information (name, address, phone, email, and IP) in response to valid emergency requests from police related to "imminent danger of death or serious physical injury to any person."[^10]
So while making your transactions private can help maintain your day-to-day privacy on Venmo, it‘s important to know that your data could still be obtained by police if your account gets caught up in a criminal investigation. As they say, the best way to keep a secret is not to have it in the first place.
Maximizing Your Venmo Privacy and Security: Tips from the Experts
Now that you understand how Venmo collects and shares your sensitive financial data, let‘s talk about some steps you can take to protect your privacy and keep your account secure. Here are some top tips I‘ve compiled from interviews with data privacy experts and my own experience covering retail and consumer issues:
-
Only use Venmo with people you know and trust. Avoid making transactions with strangers or unfamiliar businesses, as this increases your risk of fraud and scams. Venmo‘s User Agreement states that personal accounts can‘t be used to receive payment for goods and services.[^11]
-
Choose a strong, unique password and enable two-factor authentication. This extra layer of security will help prevent unauthorized access to your account. You can enable 2FA in the Venmo app under Settings > Security.
-
Keep your transactions and friend list private. As we covered earlier, changing your privacy settings is the best way to make sure your Venmo activity isn‘t exposed to the entire internet. You can also toggle off the option to appear in other users‘ friend lists.
-
Don‘t link your Venmo to social media accounts. You may be tempted to connect Venmo to Facebook to make it easier to find friends on the app. But this allows Venmo to collect even more personal information from your social profile and share your activity across platforms.
-
Monitor your account regularly for suspicious activity. Keep an eye out for transactions you don‘t recognize and contact Venmo immediately if you suspect fraud. You can also set up alerts to notify you of every payment.
-
Use your Venmo balance or a credit card as your payment method instead of your bank account. Credit card transactions have additional fraud protections and are less risky than granting Venmo direct access to your checking or savings.
-
Delete unused bank accounts, credit cards, and friends from the app. The less data you have stored on Venmo, the lower your risk if your account gets hacked or exposed in a breach. Go through your settings regularly and remove any info you no longer need.
-
Consider using a digital wallet like Apple Cash or Google Pay instead. These mobile payment apps tend to have stricter privacy policies and don‘t have social features like a public feed that can reveal your activity.
-
If you decide to close your Venmo account, contact customer service to make sure it‘s fully deactivated. Remember, even then Venmo will retain an archived copy of your profile and transaction history. The only way to completely delete it is to file a formal erasure request.[^12]
-
Opt out of Venmo‘s arbitration clause in your account settings. This preserves your right to pursue legal action against the company in court if they mishandle your data.[^13]
Ultimately, using any digital payment service comes with inherent privacy risks. But by staying informed, adjusting your account settings, and being mindful of how you use these apps, you can dramatically reduce the chances of your data being exposed or exploited.
As consumer privacy expert Katie McInnis reminds us:
"You have a choice in what you want to share and who you want to share it with. Companies are not entitled to your personal information just because you are using their service. It‘s okay to ask questions, read the fine print, and make decisions based on your privacy values."[^14]
Moving Forward: Balancing Convenience and Privacy in the Venmo Age
Venmo and other peer-to-peer payment apps have undoubtedly made it easier than ever to digitally send and receive money. But as we‘ve seen, that convenience often comes at the cost of our privacy and security. In an age of widespread data collection, breaches, and exploitation, it‘s more important than ever for consumers to educate themselves about how their information is being used and take steps to protect it.
While we wait for stronger regulations around financial data privacy, there are still things we can do as individual users to minimize risks and safeguard our accounts. By following best practices like using strong passwords, enabling privacy settings, and monitoring for fraud, we can enjoy the benefits of Venmo while also maintaining control over our sensitive information.
At the end of the day, it‘s up to each of us to decide where we draw the line between convenience and privacy. What feels right for one person may be too exposing for another. The key is to make those choices consciously and with a clear understanding of the potential tradeoffs.
As Venmo continues to grow and evolve, I hope this guide has given you the knowledge and tools to navigate your account settings with confidence. Stay safe out there, and happy Venmoing!
Sources:
[^1]: Venmo Revenue and Usage Statistics (2023)[^2]: Public By Default: The Publicity of Venmo Transactions
[^3]: Your Privacy Rights – Venmo
[^4]: Venmo Privacy Policy
[^5]: Venmo Is Sharing Your Data More Than You Think
[^6]: Consumer Privacy Survey Findings 2020 – Consumer Reports
[^7]: ‘Erratic‘ Paige Thompson Arrested After Capital One Hack Hits 106M People
[^8]: The High-Flying Venmo Transactions of the Fyre Festival Fraudster
[^9]: FBI Probing Proud Boys Venmo Payments Ahead of Capitol Riot
[^10]: Venmo Law Enforcement Guidelines
[^11]: Venmo User Agreement
[^12]: Venmo Support – Closing Your Venmo Account
[^13]: Venmo Arbitration Agreement Opt Out Instructions
[^14]: Interview with Katie McInnis, Consumer Reports data privacy expert, conducted May 2023
