In an age where our digital lives are increasingly under threat from hackers, corporate surveillance, and government spying, protecting our private communications has never been more important. Encrypted messaging offers a powerful solution, but with so many apps and conflicting information out there, it can be tough to navigate.
In this ultimate guide, we‘ll break down everything you need to know about encrypted messaging. We‘ll explore what encryption is, how it secures your conversations, and what to look for in an encrypted messaging app. Armed with this knowledge, you‘ll be able to make informed choices to safeguard your digital privacy.
Table of Contents
1. What is Encrypted Messaging?
2. How Does Encryption Work?
3. Public Key vs. Private Key Encryption
4. The Importance of End-to-End Encryption (E2EE)
5. Comparing Encrypted Messaging Apps
6. Tips for Using Encrypted Messaging Securely
7. Limitations and Other Privacy Considerations
8. Encrypted Messaging FAQs
9. Conclusion
What is Encrypted Messaging?
At its simplest, encrypted messaging is a way to communicate privately by converting your messages into a secret code that can only be read by your intended recipient. If the message is intercepted by a third party, they will only see the unintelligible coded text, not the actual content of your conversation.
Encryption has a long history dating back to ancient times, when Julius Caesar is said to have used a simple letter substitution cipher to encode sensitive military messages. Of course, modern digital encryption is far more sophisticated, using complex mathematical algorithms to scramble data in ways that are virtually impossible to crack without the decryption key.
According to a 2021 study by the Ponemon Institute, the global adoption of encryption solutions increased 17% over the previous year, with 50% of organizations now having an enterprise-wide encryption strategy. However, there is still significant room for growth, with the average company having only 41% of its sensitive data encrypted.
How Does Encryption Work?
Modern encryption relies on the science of cryptography and the power of mathematics. When you send an encrypted message, it is transformed from readable plaintext into ciphertext using an encryption algorithm and an encryption key.
The encryption algorithm is a set of mathematical instructions that define how the plaintext will be converted. The encryption key is a string of characters that is fed into the algorithm to encode or decode the data. You can think of the algorithm as a lock and the key as the combination to open it.
There are two main types of encryption algorithms in use today:
-
Symmetric key algorithms use the same key to encrypt and decrypt the data. Both the sender and receiver need to have the key to communicate. Examples include AES (Advanced Encryption Standard) and DES (Data Encryption Standard).
-
Public key algorithms, also known as asymmetric cryptography, use two linked keys – a public key that can be freely shared for encrypting messages and a private key that is kept secret for decrypting them. Examples include RSA (Rivest–Shamir–Adleman) and ECC (Elliptic Curve Cryptography).
According to Google‘s 2021 research, its open-source AEAD Encryption algorithm for low-powered devices achieved over 500,000 encryptions per second on an Intel processor, while still remaining highly memory efficient.
Public Key vs. Private Key Encryption
Understanding the difference between public key and private key encryption is crucial for grasping how secure messaging works.
In symmetric (private key) encryption, the same key is used on both ends. This key must be securely shared between parties before any messages are sent, which can pose a challenge. If the key is intercepted by an attacker during transmission, the entire conversation could be compromised. Symmetric encryption is very fast and efficient for encrypting large amounts of data.
Asymmetric (public key) encryption solves the key distribution problem by using two separate keys. Each user has their own key pair consisting of a private key and a public key. The public key can be freely shared with anyone who wants to send you a message. Once a message is encrypted with your public key, it can only be decrypted with your corresponding private key, which you keep strictly to yourself.
Here‘s a simplified example:
- Alice wants to send Bob an encrypted message.
- Alice looks up Bob‘s public key in a directory or asks him directly.
- Alice encrypts her plaintext message to Bob using his public key and sends it.
- The encrypted message travels over the public internet. Even if it‘s intercepted, no one else can decipher it.
- Bob receives the encrypted message and decrypts it with his private key.
- Bob can reply to Alice using the same process with Alice‘s public key.
Asymmetric encryption provides a solid foundation for secure communication, but it is slower than symmetric encryption due to the complex math involved. In practice, most messaging apps use a hybrid approach with asymmetric encryption to securely establish a shared secret key, which is then used for faster symmetric encryption of the actual messages.
The Importance of End-to-End Encryption (E2EE)
While any encryption is better than sending messages in plain text, not all encryption is created equal in terms of privacy. The gold standard that you should insist on for truly secure messaging is end-to-end encryption (E2EE).
In E2EE, messages are encrypted on the sender‘s device before leaving and only decrypted on the recipient‘s device. No one in between, not even the messaging service provider, can read the contents of the messages. E2EE ensures that your private conversations stay between you and your intended recipient alone.
Without E2EE, your messages may still be encrypted in transit between your device and the service provider‘s servers, but the service provider itself holds the keys and has the ability to access your unencrypted messages. This arrangement requires you to trust the provider not to snoop on your conversations or hand over your data to third parties.
There have been numerous cases of messaging providers being compelled by law enforcement to silently monitor targeted users or handing over chat logs in response to subpoenas. In 2020, the US Department of Justice subpoenaed Twitter for information on certain users‘ direct messages as part of an investigation into potential foreign influence campaigns.
Even if you trust your provider, a hacker could still potentially breach their servers and gain access to the keys to decrypt all of the stored conversations. In the massive Yahoo data breach of 2013, attackers were able to access the cryptographic keys used to encrypt all user emails, putting the private messages of 3 billion accounts at risk.
With proper E2EE, you don‘t have to worry about these threats. Even if a messaging provider‘s servers are hacked or the company is subpoenaed, they simply don‘t have the technical ability to decrypt your conversations.
According to a 2020 survey by the Pew Research Center, about 40% of Americans reported using some form of encrypted messaging. But 85% said they had not had an in-depth discussion about the privacy implications of encrypted messaging.
Comparing Encrypted Messaging Apps
With over 100 "secure" messaging apps now available, choosing the right one can seem daunting. But once you know what to look for in terms of encryption and privacy, it becomes much easier to narrow down the field. Let‘s compare some of the most popular options:
| App | Encryption Protocol | E2EE Default | Open Source | Collects Metadata |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Signal | Signal Protocol | Yes | Yes | Minimal |
| Signal Protocol | Yes | No | Yes | |
| iMessage | Proprietary | Yes* | No | Yes |
| Telegram | MTProto | No (opt-in Secret Chats only) | Partially | Yes |
| Threema | NaCl | Yes | Yes | Minimal |
*iMessage E2EE only when messaging other iMessage users over Wi-Fi/data.
Signal is widely regarded by security experts as the gold standard for encrypted messaging. It uses its own open source Signal Protocol, now the most widely adopted E2EE protocol. All communications on Signal are E2EE by default. Signal is run by a non-profit foundation and collects minimal user metadata. However, you do have to register with a phone number.
WhatsApp, the most popular messaging app globally with over 2 billion users, adopted the Signal Protocol for E2EE in 2016. While this makes WhatsApp conversations very secure, the app does collect extensive metadata about users that its parent company Facebook has misused for ad targeting. In 2021, WhatsApp came under fire for an update to its privacy policy that allowed even more data sharing with Facebook.
iMessage provides E2EE for messaging other Apple users over Wi-Fi/data, but falls back to insecure SMS/MMS when messaging non-Apple users. iMessage‘s proprietary encryption and lack of third-party audits have led some experts to question its security compared to Signal. Apple also holds iMessage encryption keys in its data centers for backup and sync across a user‘s Apple devices.
Telegram offers E2EE but not by default. You have to start a "Secret Chat" and E2EE is only supported for 1:1 chats, not group chats. Telegram‘s MTProto encryption protocol is custom-developed and lacks thorough independent audits like Signal‘s. Telegram collects user metadata and allows users to find each other by phone number by default.
Threema is a lesser-known but highly secure option. It uses the open source NaCl library for end-to-end encryption of all messages, voice calls, and even status messages. You can use Threema anonymously without providing a phone number or email address. Minimal user data is collected. The main downside is a smaller user base and lack of some features compared to mainstream apps.
No matter which app you choose, remember that E2EE only protects the content of your messages, not the metadata (who you‘re talking to, when, and for how long). For maximum privacy, consider additional tools like VPNs and anonymous accounts.
Tips for Using Encrypted Messaging Securely
Choosing a secure encrypted messaging app is a great start, but how you use it is just as important. Here are some tips to get the most security out of your private conversations:
-
Make sure you‘re using end-to-end encryption, not just client-server encryption. Check your app settings.
-
Keep your messaging apps and device operating systems updated for the latest security patches and features. Enable automatic updates.
-
Set messages to auto-delete after a certain time period for added privacy and less data to secure. Most secure messaging apps have this option.
-
Always verify the identity of new contacts within the app itself before sharing sensitive info. Most E2EE apps provide a unique safety number or QR code to compare.
-
Beware of phishing attempts and never open links or download files within a messaging app from untrusted sources. These could compromise the security of your device and chats.
-
If you are backing up your messages in the cloud, ensure those backups are also E2EE and protected with a strong unique passphrase. Better yet, keep backups locally on an external encrypted drive.
-
Set a strong app password in addition to your device passcode. This is especially important for Telegram which doesn‘t encrypt chats by default.
-
Consider using a secure VPN to add an extra layer of encryption to your internet connection and mask your IP address, which could be linked to your identity.
Limitations and Other Privacy Considerations
While encrypted messaging is a powerful privacy tool, it‘s not a silver bullet. It‘s important to understand the limitations and trade-offs involved.
For starters, E2EE only protects the content of your messages in transit and on the provider‘s servers. It doesn‘t stop the person on the other end from showing, saving, or forwarding your messages or files to a third party.
Additionally, encryption doesn‘t hide the metadata of your conversations – who you are messaging, the date/time and message frequency. A 2015 study by Stanford University found that basic metadata alone can reveal sensitive details like health conditions, hobbies, and relationships.
Most encrypted messaging apps also require you to register with some form of ID like a phone number or email address, creating another vector to link your identity and usage patterns. If maximum anonymity is desired, consider an app that lets you sign up without an ID, like Session or Threema.
Encryption is only as strong as the security of your devices. If your phone or computer is hacked or infected with malware, your encrypted conversations could still be compromised. Always use a strong unique device passcode and be cautious about the apps and files you download.
Finally, understand that encrypted messaging won‘t hide your communications from legal requests in all cases. With a valid warrant or court order, law enforcement can still compel you to decrypt your device or hand over your encryption keys under certain circumstances.
Be thoughtful about what you put in writing, even with encryption, as you may be legally required to disclose it. For the most sensitive matters, consider having conversations in person.
Encrypted Messaging FAQs
Q: Can encrypted messages be hacked?
A: With proper end-to-end encryption using a modern encryption algorithm, it would take a supercomputer billions of years to guess the decryption key to hack the messages. However, encryption is only as secure as the devices on either end. If a hacker gains access to your unlocked device, they could still read your encrypted conversations.
Q: What happens if I lose my phone with encrypted messages on it?
A: If you have a strong passcode on your phone, your encrypted messages will remain secure. Most encrypted messaging apps also offer a remote wipe option to delete all messages from a lost device. For added security, make sure your messaging app requires a separate password from your device passcode.
Q: Can police recover encrypted messages?
A: In most cases, no. With proper end-to-end encryption, the messaging provider does not have access to the decryption keys and cannot turn over readable messages to law enforcement, even under subpoena. However, if police gain access to your unlocked device, they may be able to read your messages. In some jurisdictions, you could also be compelled under warrant to decrypt your own conversations.
Q: Is WhatsApp safe for private conversations?
A: WhatsApp offers robust end-to-end encryption for messages using the Signal Protocol. However, WhatsApp shares extensive metadata with its parent company Facebook. For maximum privacy, consider a more secure alternative like Signal.
Conclusion
In an era of pervasive data breaches, corporate tracking, and government surveillance, taking back control over your digital privacy is more important than ever. Encrypted messaging is a critical tool in your privacy toolbox, offering an easy way to protect your conversations from prying eyes.
By understanding how encryption secures your messages, you‘ll be better equipped to choose the right messaging app and use it safely. Remember, not all encrypted messaging is created equal – look for apps that offer end-to-end encryption by default, with minimal metadata collection.
Ultimately, the privacy of your conversations is in your hands. By being proactive about using strong encryption, secure devices, and smart communication practices, you‘ll be well on your way to keeping your private life private in the digital age.
